The aim of this study was to compare depressive symptoms, quality of life, and worry between people living with HIV and community controls. The results showed that people living with HIV reported significantly higher depressive symptoms and lower quality of life than controls, whereas the two groups did not differ significantly in worry. In the logistic regression model, age and depressive symptoms were associated with group membership; however, these associations were attenuated in a sensitivity analysis that included education.
One of the principal findings of the present study was the higher level of depressive symptoms among people living with HIV compared with community controls. Several factors may contribute to this group difference, including dissatisfaction with life circumstances, poor somatic health, perceived stigma, and treatment-related challenges (
28). In addition, the neurotropic effects of HIV and the potential neuropsychiatric effects of long-term antiretroviral therapy have been proposed as contributors to mood disturbances (
29); these mechanisms were not examined in the present study.
People living with HIV in the present study reported significantly lower quality of life than controls, consistent with previous research in this population (
15,
17). Several factors may contribute to this difference, including socioeconomic conditions, immunological status, HIV-related symptoms, and psychological comorbidity, particularly depression, which have been associated with health-related quality of life among people living with HIV (
30).
Contrary to what might be expected given the elevated GAD prevalence in HIV, no significant between-group difference was observed in worry (d = 0.17). This finding may reflect a conceptual distinction between worry as a trait-like cognitive process and the diagnosis-specific construct of generalized anxiety disorder. Although GAD prevalence has been shown to be elevated among people with HIV (
22), worry itself may represent a widespread cognitive vulnerability that is not specific to HIV status. Alternatively, this null finding could reflect a shared elevated baseline of worry across both groups due to broader socioeconomic stressors in the study context (
31) or limited statistical power. In the Iranian context, this study is among the first to examine worry as a distinct cognitive process among people living with HIV, and these findings should be replicated in larger samples.
In the primary logistic model, older age and higher depressive symptoms were each associated with higher odds of belonging to the HIV group, whereas quality of life and worry were not independently associated with group membership. Depressive symptoms were therefore the only measured psychological variable associated with group membership in this model. However, the groups differed markedly in educational attainment, and when education was added in a sensitivity analysis (n = 105), the association for depressive symptoms was attenuated and its confidence interval approached the null value, while the association for age was no longer statistically significant. These findings suggest that the association between depression and group membership is sensitive to adjustment for education, and residual confounding by education and other unmeasured factors cannot be excluded.
These findings may have implications for mental health care within HIV services in Iran. The higher depressive symptoms observed among people living with HIV support further evaluation of mental health assessment and psychosocial support in this setting. However, this study did not evaluate any screening strategy or intervention; therefore, conclusions about diagnostic performance, intervention effectiveness, or population-level benefit cannot be drawn, and these questions require longitudinal and interventional research. Because participants were recruited through convenience sampling in Tehran, with the HIV group drawn from a single specialist center, generalizability to other settings is limited.
5.1. Limitations and Future Directions
First, the cross-sectional design precludes causal conclusions about the temporal relationship between depression and HIV status, including whether pre-existing depressive vulnerability increased risk behaviors leading to infection or whether depressive symptoms emerged in response to the diagnosis and its consequences. Longitudinal studies tracking newly diagnosed cohorts are needed to clarify this temporal relationship.
Second, sex and socioeconomic status were reported by only a small number of participants (sex: 8 of 48 in the HIV group and 5 of 71 controls; socioeconomic status: 15 and 10, respectively), and marital status and employment status were not collected. Consequently, these variables could not be included in the analyses, limiting our ability to assess their potential confounding effects. The control group also had a significantly higher level of educational attainment (χ
2(
2) = 27.50, P < 0.001). Education was not included in the primary logistic model because all 11 missing values occurred in the control group. In a sensitivity analysis that added dichotomized education (n = 105), university-level education was strongly associated with control-group membership, the association for depressive symptoms was attenuated (OR = 0.86, 95% CI [0.75, 1.00]), and the association for age was no longer significant. Residual confounding by educational differences, sex, socioeconomic status, and other unmeasured factors therefore cannot be excluded. The primary group comparisons (independent-samples t tests) were also unadjusted for age and education. Both groups were recruited through convenience sampling, and the HIV group consisted of patients available at a single specialist center, which limits generalizability beyond this setting. In addition, the questionnaires were completed in different settings (a clinical center for the HIV group and varied community locations for controls), which may have influenced responses.
Third, the relatively modest sample size of the HIV group (n = 48) may have provided insufficient statistical power to detect small effect sizes in trait worry, potentially increasing the risk of type II error. All psychological variables were self-reported and may therefore be affected by social desirability and reporting bias. Quality of life was analyzed as the summed total of all 26 WHOQOL-BREF items rather than as separate domain scores; future studies could examine domain-specific differences. In addition, the area under the ROC curve was estimated in the same sample used to fit the model and is likely optimistic.
Finally, biomedical information, including CD4+ T-cell count, plasma viral load, time since diagnosis, and ART regimen, was not collected. HIV status in the HIV group was based on a diagnosis documented in clinical records and established through the center's standard diagnostic procedure, without review of individual laboratory results by the research team. HIV-negative status among controls was self-reported rather than laboratory-verified. Furthermore, other medical and psychiatric conditions were not screened for in the control group, so controls may differ from the HIV group in comorbidity and other health-related characteristics. Incorporating detailed clinical markers alongside standardized psychiatric diagnostic interviews is an important direction for future multicenter research.
5.2. Conclusions
In conclusion, people living with HIV in this sample exhibited significantly higher depressive symptoms and lower quality of life than community controls, whereas worry did not differ significantly between groups. Depressive symptoms were associated with HIV-group membership after accounting for age, but this association was attenuated when education was added in a sensitivity analysis, and residual confounding cannot be excluded. These findings support further evaluation of mental health assessment and psychosocial support within HIV clinical care in Tehran, Iran; however, causal conclusions and the effectiveness of specific screening or intervention strategies require longitudinal and interventional research.