This study confirmed that the administration of herbal combination contained Fenugreek and Fennel. Chicory has significant beneficial effects on weight gain, improvement in appetite, and quality of life in patients suffering from cancer-induced cachexia and anorexia after 8 weeks’ follow-up without any significant toxicity or complication. The protective mechanism, by which herbal combination led to weight loss attenuation, was not entirely understood. The proposed mechanism arises from the modulation of the inflammatory response by ingredients like Fenugreek and Chicory (
16,
17). However, finding the exact effective mechanism of the herbal combination needs to be discovered through the cellular and molecular pathway in animal and clinical studies.
During this preliminary study, the beneficiary effects of the herbal combination were proved. The effects should be checked through serum biomarkers and sort of inflammatory cytokines to assess the meticulous impact of the herbal combination on cellular function.
The administration of anti-inflammatory drugs has been always a matter of concern for attenuating the cascade of inflammation in cancer-induced cachexia and anorexia, although conflicting results have been noted in previous studies (
22,
23).
For example, in a pilot study conducted by Lain et al. on patients suffering from head and neck and gastrointestinal cancer-induced cachexia, the administration of celecoxib 200 mg twice daily showed a 1-kilogram weight gain, improvement in BMI and quality of life score, whereas, in the placebo group, the weight loss of 1.3 kg was observed (
14). However, the levels of circulating pro-inflammatory cytokine were not statistically different between the treatment and control groups.
In similar studies, in a Japanese clinical trial conducted in 2016, 100 mg anamorelin, an analog of ghrelin, was administrated to the non-small cell lung cancers suffering from cancer-induced cachexia for 12 weeks. The results revealed that anamorelin increased the serum biomarkers such as insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) IGF-1, IGF binding protein-3 (IGFBP-3), and prealbumin significantly in comparison with the placebo group. However, there was no significant difference in other inflammatory serum markers such as TNF and ILs (
23). Again in this study, the significant decline in the level of inflammatory cytokines was not confirmed. Furthermore, according to protective results in weight gain and other criteria, one should conclude that the suppression of proinflammatory cytokine is not the only considered protective mechanism and possibly the other unclear mechanism is in charge and must be revealed.
The other proposed effective mechanism of the herbal combination in improving cancer-induced cachexia is a direct effect of these herbal ingredients on cancer-induced anorexia. For instance, the anti-diabetic and appetizing effects of Fenugreek seeds by enhancing insulin release were proved in different animal (
24) and clinical studies (
25). In this study, the significant appetite enhancement was seen in our recruited patients and was confirmed, using the Edmonton scale.
The results showed that the 8-week administration of the herbal combination in adjunctive with megestrol (160 mg/day) caused a significant increase in cancer patients’ weight in comparison with placebo combination and megestrol (160 mg/day). The similar promising results have been proposed by numerous agents such as thalidomide (
13) and L-carnitine supplementation (
15).
For example, in line with our results, Gordon et al. in 2005 in a placebo-controlled clinical trial indicated that 200 mg thalidomide daily has a notable effect on weight and anthropometric indices. Patients in the thalidomide group had gained, on average, 0.37 kg in weight compared with a loss of 2.21 kg (absolute difference 2.59 kg) in the placebo group (
13). In a similar trial, L-carnitine (4 gram, daily) has been used for cancer-induced cachexia and significant weight improvement in the interventional group after 6 weeks follow-up was noted (
15).
It should be noted that not all examined agents succeeded to show weight enhancement properties. For example, in a randomized clinical trial using cyproheptadine, 8 mg orally 3 times a day in patients with advanced malignancies, cyproheptadine did not significantly abate progressive weight loss in these patients with the advanced fatal disease. Patients who had assigned to cyproheptadine arm lost weight by an average of 4.5 pounds per month compared with 4.9 pounds per month in the placebo arm (
26). Although weight gaining properties from cyproheptadine have been reported in the earlier studies, the anti-wasting effects of cyproheptadine were not demonstrated in cachectic patients suffering from cancers.
In another study, Del Fabbro et al. performed a randomized, double-blinded, 28-day trial of melatonin 20 mg versus placebo in patients with advanced lung or gastrointestinal cancers to investigate the effects of melatonin in weight, appetite, and quality of life improvement. After the interim analysis of 48 patients, the study has been halted due to an insignificant difference between comparable variants (
27). Furthermore, melatonin failed to show any compelling results in cancer-induced cachexia.
According to our encouraging data, having administrated by the herbal combination in cachectic patients not only led to weight gain but also could improve quality of life, FAACT score, and anthropometric indices during an 8-week follow-up. It reflects this fact that 8 weeks was suitable enough to indicate the positive effects of the herbal combination in the overall health and life condition of patients with cancer.
As mentioned in Gordon et al.’s study (
13), thalidomide induced a notable effect on weight and anthropometric indices of patients with cancer while significant improvement in the quality of life after a 4-week follow-up was not shown.
According to the data, it seems that reaching the quality of life improvement needs a longer duration of follow-up in comparison with other indices and the criteria could ameliorate in the studies lasted for more than 8 weeks. For example, in line with our results, Kraft M et al. could demonstrate the notable effects of L-carnitine (4 gram, daily) after a 12-week follow-up while they could not prove any significance after 6-week follow-up. Therefore, one can conclude that changing in some parameters such as quality of life possibly requires more span of times; meanwhile, the shorter follow-up periods seem to be adequate for detecting changes in the appetite and patients’ weight score.
The findings of the study suggested the potential limitations associated with conducting a randomized controlled trial concerning herbal combination for the treatment of cancer-induced cachexia; firstly, the limited number of eligible patients due to the stringent exclusion and inclusion criteria which has been restricted the vast range of patients’ recruitment and, secondly, having a short time of follow-up, limited to 8 weeks due to acceleration in patient’s dropouts and termination in patients’ drug adherence.
Taken all limitations together, as our knowledge serves, this is the only study demonstrating the potential effects of the traditional herbal combination on the management of cancer-induced complications such as cachexia or anorexia. This herbal combination can effectively be used as a safe substitute for proposed chemical medicines such as megestrol with several adverse effects. The concern is rising over the use of megestrol as a standard agent for the management of cancer-induced cachexia, especially for patients who are at risk of thromboembolic events.
Based on the experience from the study, perhaps future trials for assessing the potential effects of agents for the treatment of cancer-induced anorexia/cachexia in patients who have advanced cancer should be conducted in less stringent entry criteria, a larger sample, and longer follow-up. Our suggested herbal combination might also be a more effective therapy if used much earlier in the disease trajectory, and this should be a consideration in the design of any future intervention trial for appetite or cachexia.
5.1. Conclusions
Given the ameliorated results from the herbal combination supplementation contained Fenugreek, Fennel, Chicory in terms of weight gain and appetite improvement as well as physical and quality of life enhancement, it seems that the herbal combination can be used as an adjunctive treatment for patients suffering from cancer-induced cachexia and anorexia. However, further studies with larger sample sizes and longer follow-up periods are warranted.