The present study aimed to examine the prevalence of sports injuries among swimmers and assess the predictive capacity of the YBT-UQ and YBT-LQ. The findings indicated that age was the only significant predictor of injury risk (OR = 1.025, P = 0.027), with each additional year increasing the likelihood of injury by 2.5%. In contrast, demographic variables, training-related factors, normalized limb length, and all YBT-UQ measures showed no significant association with injury status. Among YBT-LQ components, only the posteromedial reach distance of the left leg approached statistical significance (P = 0.012), suggesting a weak predictive value.
The results of this study are partially consistent with previous research findings. Specifically, studies by Gorman et al. (
11) and Bauer et al. (
12) also demonstrated that the YBT-UQ is a reliable tool for assessing upper limb function but has limited applicability in predicting injuries. This consistency suggests that the YBT-UQ may be more suitable for evaluating neuromuscular control and overall functional performance rather than predicting sports injuries. However, our findings contradict those of Butler et al. (
13) and Cosio-Lima et al. (
14), who confirmed an association between YBT-UQ performance and injury risk. This discrepancy could be due to differences in the study population (swimmers versus athletes from other sports), assessment conditions, or controlled variables.
Additionally, Wright et al. (
15) and Lai et al. (
16) reported that the YBT-LQ alone is not a valid predictor of lower extremity injuries, particularly in collegiate athletes from various sports. Our findings support this conclusion, indicating that the YBT-LQ may have similar limitations for swimmers.
One possible explanation for these discrepancies is the difference in skill levels and movement patterns required in swimming compared to other sports. Swimming involves unique movement patterns and does not require significant weight-bearing on the lower limbs, whereas the YBT-LQ is primarily designed for land-based sports that demand stability and motor control in the lower extremities. This factor may explain why only one YBT-LQ variable (posteromedial reach distance of the left leg) approached statistical significance.
The identification of age as the only significant predictor of injury could be attributed to increased training load and biomechanical changes associated with aging in swimmers. Aging may lead to decreased flexibility, reduced muscular endurance, and slower recovery after injuries, all of which can elevate injury risk. This finding aligns with the results of Lisman et al. (
17), who demonstrated that age is a key factor in increasing injury risk among high school athletes. This limitation is due to the accessibility of the target swimmer population.
Furthermore, the lack of a significant association between training variables (number of training sessions, session duration, and weekly training volume) and injuries suggests that training intensity alone is not the primary determinant of injury risk in swimmers. This implies that other factors, such as swimming technique, adequate rest, and recovery strategies, may play a crucial role in injury occurrence — factors that were not examined in this study.
This study has several limitations that should be considered when interpreting the findings. First, it was conducted on a specific population of swimmers aged 15 to 60 years, and the results may not be generalizable to other age groups or sports disciplines. Second, variables such as flexibility, muscular endurance, and swimming technique, which may influence injury occurrence, were not examined. Third, the use of cross-sectional data limits the ability to establish causal relationships, highlighting the need for longitudinal studies to investigate this issue more thoroughly.
5.1. Conclusions
The findings of this study indicate that the Y-Balance Tests have limitations as screening tools for injury risk in swimmers, with age emerging as the only significant predictor. Therefore, using these tests alone for injury risk assessment in swimmers is not recommended. Instead, they are best applied in combination with other functional assessments and biomechanical or performance-related factors. To enhance prediction accuracy, it is suggested to integrate the Y-Balance Tests with additional evaluations, such as motion analysis, muscle strength testing, and swimming technique assessment.