Abstract
Background:
As the reciprocal effect between mind and body has been controversial since Freud's era, current research considers the relationship between the peripheral nervous system and psychological functions.Objectives:
The current study aimed to examine parasympathetic activity concerning attachment style. Heart rate variability (HRV) has been assessed. It takes an account as an index of the autonomic nervous system, which included high frequency (HF), low frequency (LF), and very low frequency (VLF), was assessed. It is noteworthy that HF is an indicator of the parasympathetic nervous system.Methods:
The study methodologically was casual-comparative. The participants included participants over 25 years-old residing in areas one to ten of Tehran. According to the agreement in casual-comparative studies, using a convenience sampling method, 36 participants opted. After missing 7 participants, 29 remained, divided into two groups based on their attachment style (12 participants in the insecure group and 17 ones in the secure group). The Persian version of Besharat's Attachment Adult Inventory (1987) and stress response evaluation (SRE) was conducted, and MANOVA performed an analysis to collect the data.Results:
Findings showed that although there is a significant difference based on combining scores of VLF, LF, and HF between two groups (F = 10.493, P < 0.05, ɳ2 = 0.557), HF is of higher average in the insecure attachment group (F = 27.70, P < 0.05, ɳ2 = 0.506).Conclusions:
Heart rate variability, especially HF, is an indicator of the parasympathetic branch of the autonomic nervous system that can be influenced by attachment style and early relationship.Keywords
Attachment Heart Rate Variability Object Attachment Parasympathetic Nervous System Peripheral Nervous System Psychophysiology Psychosomatic Medicine
1. Background
When it comes to attachment, the types and its pathology, Bowlby is the first scientist who comes to our mind. This child's early experiences with a caregiver are internalized in the form of representations of self and others, and Bowlby entitled them Internal Working Models (1). Based on the theory, insecure attachment may lead to a complex internal world and a plethora of pathological conditions (2).
Accompanied by psychological components, there are noticeable studies that show physical components have their role in the relation between infant and caregiver (3). The relationship between insecure attachment and physical problems was explored from four perspectives: (1) Correlation between becoming ailment and insecure attachment in childhood; (2) correlation between developing the disease and insecure attachment in adulthood; (3) correlation between symptoms of insecure attachment in childhood and disease at an older age; (4) correlation between secure attachment and health quality in children and adults (4).
Many studies have shown the relationship between attachment style and autonomic nervous system function (5). Studies in pathological development have indicated that a child's psychophysiological reaction to insecure attachment and mother relationship consists of two different responses: Hyperarousal and dissociation (6, 7). Prolonged stress and an inappropriate relational atmosphere separate the child from the external environment and cause helplessness and hopelessness. Damaged children stare into space and passively come into dead positions (8). Steven Porges considers this stage as the prominence of the Parasympathetic system. He believes that "the rapid and abrupt transition from the unsuccessful strategy of the fight requires sympathetic system activation to being motionless with activation of the vagus nerve and parasympathetic activity" (9, 10).
Among the various available non-invasive techniques for assessing the autonomic status, heart rate variability (HRV) has emerged as a simple, non-invasive method to evaluate the sympathovagal balance (11). The HRV refers to the variation in time intervals between heartbeats (beat-to-beat intervals). Respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA) and high-frequency HRV (HF-HRV, in the 0.15 - 0.40 Hz range) are established measures used to quantify vagal tone and to evaluate the activity of the parasympathetic nervous system (12).
2. Objectives
According to the previous research, the objective of this study was to explore the parasympathetic nervous system's activity between secure and insecure attachment groups. The HRV as an index of the autonomic nervous system with HF, Lf, and VLF elements should be evaluated. Among the three indexes, HF as a representation of the parasympathetic nervous system plays a key role in the relationship with attachment style.
3. Methods
3.1. Study Design
The study was a fundamental causative-comparative conducted in Tehran, Iran, during winter 2020. Subjects were gathered by the Convenience Sampling method. Sample numbers were according to an agreement as to at least the number of sampling in causative-comparative studies.
3.2. Participants
A total sample of 29 participants (17 secure attachment, mean age: 31.11, SD: 3.29) (12 insecure attachment, mean age: 34.71, SD: 3.63) were recruited. The education data was mentioned in Table 1. Inclusion Criteria were a minimum age of 25, university grade at least bachelor, participant's agreement to participate in the study. They were excluded if they were diagnosed with a chronic physical disease such as MS, Cancer, or severe psychological illness like psychotic or mania symptoms, a background of hospitalization due to suicidal attempts or other psychological problems, diagnosed with Trauma Brain Injury and epilepsy, and abusing drugs or alcohol. Using caffeine materials such as tea, coffee 8 hours before doing the stress response evaluation (SRE) test, taking any psychological medicine in general, and pain killer 8 hours before doing the SRE test was abandoned.
Demographic Data for Insecure and Secure Attachment People a
| Variables | Secure (n = 12) | Insecure (n = 17) |
|---|---|---|
| Education | ||
| Bachelor | 6 (35.3) | 7 (58.3) |
| Master | 10 (58.8) | 3 (25.0) |
| PhD | 1 (5.9) | 2 (16.7) |
3.3. Measures
3.3.1. Demographic Characteristics Checklist
The researchers developed the checklist and used it for the patient's demographic characteristics, including education, gender, marital status, job, and history of psychotic or hospitalization due to the family's psychological problems.
3.3.2. Adult Attachment Inventory
Adult Attachment Inventory (AAI) is a self-reported questionnaire with 25 items that Hazan and Shaver designed to classify adult attachments into secure, avoidant, and anxious/ambivalent clusters. Participants responded to the items using a five-point Likert-type scale ranging from 1 (very little) to 5 (very much). The AAI has adequate internal consistency and test-retest reliability. Cronbach alpha coefficients for the secure attachment style, avoidant attachment style, and ambivalent attachment style were respectively 0.91, 0.87, and 0.90. The temporal stability was 0.82 for secure attachment style, 0.78 for avoidant attachment style, and 0.75 for ambivalent attachment style (13).
3.3.3. Stress Response Evaluation
Stress Response Evaluation is a tool for assessing autonomic nervous system components. It is made by Thought Technology Company which contained software and hardware parts (188 Pinellas Lane, Cocoa Beach FI, 32931). The hardware part includes Flexcomp, TT-USB, EEG-Z, HR/BVP, Skin Conductance, Skin Temperature, Respiration sensors. The software part is Neuroinfiniti.
3.4. Procedure
All participants announced their consent before beginning. To determine their attachment style, they were asked to complete AAI. Respiration rate, skin conductance, temperature, and EEG sensors were installed to assess heart rate variability. The sensor for heart rate variability was installed in the middle finger. The assessment period was 5 minutes eye-opened without any stimulus in the isolated room. The ethics committee approved the current study of the University of Tehran, Iran.
3.5. Statistical Analysis
For statistical analysis of the collected data, descriptive statistics, test for checking the normality of data distribution by Kolmogorov-Smirnov, Levene's test to calculate the homogeneity of variances was conducted. MANOVA was applied to assess the difference in HRV elements between secure and insecure attachment groups. The two-tailed significance level was set at 0.05. Statistical analyses were performed by SPSS version 24.
4. Results
The demographic data was mentioned in Table 1. At first, descriptive indexes of research variables separately into two groups: (1) Secure, and (2) insecure, were submitted (Table 2). Before exploring the significance of these differences, data normality using Kolmogorov-Smirnov and homogeneity of variances by the Levene's test were assessed. According to the former test, the normality of data was accepted. Levene test results for VLF (P = 0.513, F= 0.439) and HF (P = 0.906, F = 0.014) suggested accepting homogeneity of variances. Of course, despite VLF Levene test significance (P = 0.021, F= 5.968), on the recommendation of Tabachenik and Fidel (2013), due to the approximately equal volume of both groups (less than 4 to 1 ratio), a more considerable variance can be divided into minor variance. If the result were less than 10, the analysis result of the variance would be reliable. Hence, the result was 4.48, which is an indicator of homogeneity of variances. Before analyzing, the assumption of homogenizes of a variance-covariance matrix was assessed by BOX test (F = 1.428, P = 0.200).
Mean and Standard Deviation of Research Variables a
| Variables | Secure (n = 12) | Insecure (n = 17) |
|---|---|---|
| VLF | 18.09 ± 5.75 | 12.46 ± 4.57 |
| LF | 37.97 ± 8.94 | 28.17 ± 4.22 |
| HF | 37.13 ± 6.92 | 50.69 ± 6.7 |
According to the not meaningfulness of BOX test, the Wilks Lambda was applied for comparing the groups. The test showed a significant difference between secure and insecure attachment in terms of combined scores of HF, LF, and VLF (F = 10.493, P < 0.05, ɳ2 = 0.557). The results of the test were presented to determine the differences based on dependent variables in Table 3. The results represented that the insecure group showed a higher average of HF and LF than the secure attachment group. And the low-level average of VLF in the insecure attachment group.
Analysis of Very Low Frequency, Low Frequency, High Frequency in Two Attachment Groups
| Dependent Variables | Sum of Squares | df | Mean Squares | F | Sig. | Effect Size |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| VLF | 223.232 | 1 | 223.232 | 7.937 | 0.009 | 0.227 |
| LF | 675.808 | 1 | 675.808 | 12.379 | 0.002 | 0.314 |
| HF | 1292.895 | 1 | 1292.9 | 27.701 | 0.001 | 0.506 |
Due to the significant age difference between the two groups, the effect was controlled using multivariate analysis of covariance, and the differences between the two groups in the three research variables were recalculated after controlling it. The results were that secure attachment group had higher average in LF (F = 14.518, P < 0.05, ɳ2 = 0.358). On the other hand, as to HF, the insecure attachment group showed a higher average (F = 25.031, P < 0.05, ɳ2 = 0.491). Moreover, in terms of VLF, there were no significant differences between the two groups.
5. Discussion
The present study aimed to examine the proposal that the parasympathetic system's function is different between secure and insecure attachment groups. As to the purpose, Heart Rate Variability with their elements, which were indicators of the sympathetic and parasympathetic systems, was assessed.
The results showed that there is a significant difference as of HF between secure and insecure attachment groups. The average of activity of HF is higher in the insecure attachment subjects. The finding is consistent with previous researches such as Schore and Perry's ones. They explained that early interactions of infant and caregiver not only affect psychic structures but also on a structure of peripheral and central structures (14).
Perry believed that two reactions will occur as a consequence of prolonged arousal. One of them is high arousal and the other one would be dissociation. In the latter, one is separated from his surroundings and immersed in the inner world. This state of isolation is a parasympathetic regulatory strategy that occurs in a state of despair and helplessness. When a deep and long psychological distance occurs between the child and the external object, the parasympathetic system would be openly activated (15). Putnam called the reaction "escape when there is no way to escape" (15). Porges believes that rapid and sudden transition from the unsuccessful fighting strategy, which requires sympathetic activation to an inactive state of energy storage, is associated with activity of the Vagus nerve's dorsal nucleus (16).
Schore suggested that synaptic relationships and orbitofrontal ability in coordinating and integrating the sympathetic and parasympathetic systems will be destroyed in insecure attachment conditions (12). A high level of arousal leads to high cortisol levels and sympathetic activity. However, a high level of cortisol will result in cell death. Therefore, in order to survive, conserving energy and reducing activity will be crucial. Thus, when an arousal would be chronic, increase in the parasympathetic activity and predominance of the dorsal motor part of the Vagus nerve will be increased. In the same way, chronic arousal in insecure attachment leads to a dominance of the parasympathetic system (5).
5.1. Conclusions
The present result is consistent with theoretical and empirical evidences. According to this study, the average of Hf, which is indicator of parasympathetic nervous system function, is significantly higher in insecure attachment group.
This study had some limitations. Because of the low sample size, a generalization of the results to other individuals and age groups should be made cautiously. Since the heart rate variability index was measured from a finger sensor, the probability of measurement error increased. It is also suggested that future research evaluate a broader geographical scope to provide coherent and consistent findings on variables under study. Also, other tools that can assess HRV based on chest and without medium and interview for attachment can be applied. Also, in future researches, brain mediators of this process can be explored.
References
-
1.
Fonagy P, Target M. Early Intervention and the Development of Self-Regulation. Psychoanal Inquiry. 2002;22(3):307-35. https://doi.org/10.1080/07351692209348990.
-
2.
Insel TR, Young LJ. The neurobiology of attachment. Nat Rev Neurosci. 2001;2(2):129-36. [PubMed ID: 11252992]. https://doi.org/10.1038/35053579.
-
3.
Salmon P, Young B. Dependence and caring in clinical communication: the relevance of attachment and other theories. Patient Educ Couns. 2009;74(3):331-8. [PubMed ID: 19157761]. [PubMed Central ID: PMC3764431]. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pec.2008.12.011.
-
4.
Schore AN. Affect dysregulation and disorders of the self (Norton Series on Interpersonal Neurobiology). 1st ed. New York: WW Norton & Company; 2003. 403 p.
-
5.
Schore AN. Effects of a secure attachment relationship on right brain development, affect regulation, and infant mental health. Infant Mental Health Journal. 2001;22(1-2):7-66. https://doi.org/10.1002/1097-0355(200101/04)22:1<7::Aid-imhj2>3.0.Co;2-n.
-
6.
Schore AN. Back to basics: attachment, affect regulation, and the developing right brain: linking developmental neuroscience to pediatrics. Pediatr Rev. 2005;26(6):204-17. [PubMed ID: 15930328]. https://doi.org/10.1542/pir.26-6-204.
-
7.
Schore AN. Affect Regulation and the Origin of the Self. 1st ed. New York: Taylor & Francis Group Logo; 2015. 752 p. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315680019.
-
8.
Porges SW. The polyvagal theory: Neurophysiological foundations of emotions, attachment, communication, and self-regulation (Norton series on interpersonal neurobiology). 1st ed. New York: WW Norton & Company; 2011. 347 p.
-
9.
Flores PJ, Porges SW. Group Psychotherapy as a Neural Exercise: Bridging Polyvagal Theory and Attachment Theory. Int J Group Psychother. 2017;67(2):202-22. [PubMed ID: 38449237]. https://doi.org/10.1080/00207284.2016.1263544.
-
10.
Sztajzel J. Heart rate variability: a noninvasive electrocardiographic method to measure the autonomic nervous system. Swiss medical weekly. 2004;134(3536):514-22.
-
11.
Krause-Utz A, Walther JC, Lis S, Schmahl C, Bohus M. Heart rate variability during a cognitive reappraisal task in female patients with borderline personality disorder: the role of comorbid posttraumatic stress disorder and dissociation. Psychol Med. 2019;49(11):1810-21. [PubMed ID: 30198447]. [PubMed Central ID: PMC6650777]. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0033291718002489.
-
12.
Besharat MA. Development and Validation of Adult Attachment Inventory. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences. 2011;30:475-9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2011.10.093.
-
13.
Schore AN. Relational trauma and the developing right brain: an interface of psychoanalytic self psychology and neuroscience. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2009;1159:189-203. [PubMed ID: 19379241]. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1749-6632.2009.04474.x.
-
14.
Perry BD, Pollard RA, Blakley TL, Baker WL, Vigilante D. Childhood trauma, the neurobiology of adaptation, and “use-dependent” development of the brain: How “states” become “traits”. Infant Mental Health Journal. 1995;16(4):271-91. https://doi.org/10.1002/1097-0355(199524)16:4<271::Aid-imhj2280160404>3.0.Co;2-b.
-
15.
Putnam FW. Dissociation in children and adolescents: a developmental perspective. Guilford Press; 1997.
-
16.
Porges SW. Emotion: an evolutionary by-product of the neural regulation of the autonomic nervous system. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 1997;807:62-77. [PubMed ID: 9071344]. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1749-6632.1997.tb51913.x.