1. Background
Hepatitis C virus (HCV) is a global health concern, with an estimated 130 to 170 million people infected (1, 2). HCV exhibits high genetic diversity and is classified into 7 genotypes and multiple subtypes (3). The HCV genome encodes for at least 10 structural (C, E1 and E2) and nonstructural (p7, NS2, NS3, NS4A, NS4B, NS5A and NS5B) proteins and is flanked by 5’ and 3’ untranslated regions (UTR) (4). A membrane-associated protein, NS5B, contains 591 amino acids (aa), with 21 hydrophobic aa at the C-terminus, which are responsible for membrane anchorage, and 530 aa at its N-terminus, which include the usual “fingers”, “palm” and “thumb” subdomains of all single-chain polymerases (5, 6). NS5B codes for an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) lacks proofreading ability and leads to the emergence of viral mutations both in vitro and in vivo (7). Nonetheless, NS5B is essential for HCV replication (8) and is subject to considerable purifying selection to maintain critical functions. Conserved secondary RNA structures limit NS5B diversity, while immune-mediated selection pressures also contribute to NS5B polymorphism (9-15). Immune- or drug-selected mutations in NS5B dramatically reduce viral replication in vivo, although compensatory mutations may result in more fit viruses that are less immunogenic within a particular HLA background (16, 17). Given the error rate of NS5B, it is predicted that all mutants with single or double nucleotide substitutions are generated within an infected individual on a daily basis (18).
Since 2011, multiple direct-acting antiviral agents (DAA) have been approved for the treatment of HCV infection including NS3 protease inhibitors, NS5A inhibitors, and NS5B polymerase inhibitors, with and without combination with peg-interferon (peg-IFN) and ribavirin (RBV) (19, 20). HCV NS5B has emerged as one of the major targets for development of drugs that inhibit HCV directly (21). Additionally, studies have indicated the involvement of NS5B in the response to peg-interferon + ribavirin therapy (peg-IFN/RBV) (22). Recently, the FDA approved the NS5B inhibitors including sofosbuvir and dasabuvir (23, 24). HCV mutations that reduce susceptibility to DAA therapies can occur naturally in treatment naïve patients (25, 26). These mutations have been found in patients who did not respond to DAA treatment, or who had a viral breakthrough (27). The present study aimed at evaluating NS5B treatment resistance mutations in treatment naive South Africans.
2. Methods
As described previously (28), 60 anti-HCV positive serum samples were collected at random from treatment naïve patients at Dr George Mukhari Academic hospital in Pretoria (South Africa) that serves as a major referral center for patients from the North West, Mpumalanga, Limpopo, and Gauteng provinces. Serum HCV RNA levels were quantified by an in-house real-time PCR assay based on the 5’UTR region (29).
For genotype determination, viral RNA was extracted from 140 uL of serum using the QIAamp Viral RNA Mini Kit. HCV RNA was detected by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) of the 5’UTR, core/E1, and NS5B regions. NS5B primers were shown previously to amplify HCV genotypes 1 through 6 (30). NS5B RT-PCR products were sequenced directly using the amplification primers as the sequencing primers. Phylogenetic analysis was performed using the Neighbor-Joining method in CLUSTAL W (31) and confirmed by a Bayesian Markov chain Monte Carlo approach, implemented in the Bayesian Evolutionary analysis by sampling trees (BEAST) program (32). NS5B sequences were submitted to GenBank under the following accession numbers: HQ385855-385885 and JN1165558-116566.
Demographics for 52 individuals have been described elsewhere (28) and included 28 males and 24 females, with a mean age of 54 years. The study was approved by the Medunsa research and ethics committee of the faculty of health Sciences at the University of Limpopo (now Sefako Makgatho Health Sciences University).
The current study consisted of a convenience sample of 42 HCV sequences corresponding to amino acids 228 to 335 of the HCV NS5B gene. Of these, 22 (52.4%) belonged to genotype 5a, 12 (28.6%) were genotype 4, and 8 (19.0%) were genotype 1 (4 genotype 1a and 4 genotype 1b). HCV reference sequences were downloaded from the Los Alamos database (http://hcv.lanl.gov/content/hcv-db/index), aligned by Mafft (http://mafft.cbrc.jp/alignment/server/), and translated into amino acids using BioEdit. For mutations associated with resistance, the amino acids were compared with those mutations described in the literature. Entropy plots were generated by the Shannon entropy method for each amino acid position using the BioEdit software. Entropy values greater than 0.2 were considered significant. The positions under positive and negative selection were detected via fixed effects likelihood methods (FEL) as implemented in the DataMonkey program (www.datamonkey.org), which directly estimates nonsynonymous (dN) and synonymous (dS) substitution rates at each site.
3. Results
Ribavirin-associated resistance mutations at positions D244N, Q309R, and A333E of NS5B were analyzed. The Q309R mutation was detected in 1 of 12 (8.3%) genotype 4 sequences, 4 of 4 (100%) genotype 1a sequences, and 7 of 22 (31.8%) genotype 5a sequences. Eleven (91.7%) of the genotype 4 sequences had the Q309K polymorphism. In this study, mutation D244N was not found in any sequence. Mutation A333E was detected in 11 of 22 (50%) genotype 5a sequences. Other mutations associated with peg-IFN/RBV resistance, D310N and T329I, were not found in any of the sequences analyzed.
The NS5B DAA resistance mutations S282T and C316Y/N were also evaluated. The NS5B polymorphism C316N, which is associated with resistance to HCV-796, was found in all 4 (100%) genotype 1b sequences. The S282T and C316Y mutations were not detected in any of the sequences analyzed (Table 1).
Table 1.
Sociodemographic, Clinical, and Drug Resistance Data for the 42 Individuals Included in This Study
| ID | Year | Age | Gender | ALT | AST | Genotype/Subtype | Viral Load | Resistance Mutations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ZADGM7890 | 2007 | 62 | F | 5a | 5.13^5 | |||
| ZADGM 651 | 2007 | 73 | M | 5a | 4.21^6 | |||
| ZADGM 3013 | 2010 | 63 | M | 5a | 60425 | A333E | ||
| ZADGM 9150 | 2007 | 62 | F | 5a | 96238.9 | |||
| ZADGM 7915 | 2007 | 52 | M | 5a | 86956 | Q309R | ||
| ZADGM 2582 | 2010 | 58 | F | 5a | 9.63^5 | A333E | ||
| ZADGM 308 | 2009 | 79 | M | 66 | 85 | 5a | 76778 | A333E |
| ZADGM 1908 | 2007 | 86 | M | 46 | 88 | 5a | 3.6^5 | A333E |
| ZADGM 905 | 2007 | 51 | M | 5a | 1.71^6 | Q309R | ||
| ZADGM 525gp | 2010 | 75 | F | 5a | 9.49^5 | A333E | ||
| ZADGM 869 | 2007 | 66 | F | 5a | 34746.02 | Q309R | ||
| ZADGM 1707 | 2007 | 65 | F | 5a | 91682.7 | Q309R, A333E | ||
| ZADGM 2088 | 2011 | 81 | M | 80 | 51 | 5a | 6.79^6 | Q309R, A333E |
| ZADGM 3073 | 2010 | 60 | F | 80 | 354 | 5a | 31404.67 | Q309R |
| ZADGM 9602 | 2010 | 30 | F | 5a | 1.14^5 | Q309R | ||
| ZADGM 2439 | 2010 | 37 | M | 45 | 76 | 5a | 5.65^5 | A333E |
| ZADGM 4227 | 2007 | 60 | F | 49 | 83 | 5a | 1.35^5 | Q309R |
| ZADGM 6485 | 2010 | 73 | M | 5a | 1523.01 | Q309R | ||
| ZADGM 6544 | 2007 | 63 | F | 69 | 363 | 5a | 12056.63 | A333E |
| ZADGM 7938 | 2010 | 75 | F | 5a | 28906 | |||
| ZADGM 9684 | 2010 | 21 | M | 5a | 78654 | A333E | ||
| ZADGM 8159 | 2010 | 66 | M | 5a | 1.4^6 | A333E | ||
| ZADGM 3137 | 2010 | 47 | F | 1a | 86597.78 | Q309R | ||
| ZADGM 9300 | 2010 | 45 | M | 1a | 6.4^5 | Q309R | ||
| ZADGM 909 | 2007 | 49 | M | 1a | 25329.2 | Q309R | ||
| ZADGM 2739 | 2009 | 24 | M | 1a | 17158.85 | Q309R | ||
| ZADGM 099 | 2007 | 79 | F | 1b | 67944.84 | C316N | ||
| ZADGM 986 | 2006 | 36 | F | 1b | 5687.43 | C316N | ||
| ZADGM 525 | 2009 | 89 | M | 50 | 79 | 1b | 3879.63 | C316N |
| ZADGM 221 | 2007 | 37 | F | 53 | 120 | 1b | 1.56^5 | C316N |
| ZADGM 8690 | 2009 | 70 | F | 59 | 50 | 4r | 1.65^6 | Q309K |
| ZADGM 3460 | 2010 | 66 | M | 4c | 2.51^6 | Q309R | ||
| ZADGM 4188 | 2010 | 55 | F | 57 | 54 | 4q | 2.31^6 | Q309K |
| ZADGM 3480 | 2010 | 57 | F | 4a | 2.4^5 | Q309K | ||
| ZADGM 886 | 2007 | 56 | F | 124 | 102 | 4q | 2.65^5 | Q309K |
| ZADGM 655 | 2007 | 71 | M | 69 | 845 | 4k | 7983 | Q309K |
| ZADGM 7684 | 2007 | 53 | F | 4c | 64279.41 | Q309K | ||
| ZADGM 3771 | 2010 | 62 | F | 4 | 6.75^5 | Q309K | ||
| ZADGM 6426 | 2010 | 62 | F | 125 | 97 | 4 | 7.65^5 | Q309K |
| ZADGM 9538 | 2010 | 62 | F | 4 | 7.73^5 | Q309K | ||
| ZADGM 1903 | 2006 | 52 | M | 86 | 240 | 4k | 7551.78 | Q309K |
| ZADGM 225 | 2007 | 53 | F | 4c | 3.33^5 | Q309K |
Abbreviations: ALT, alanine aminotransferase; AST, aspartate aminotransferase; F, female; M, male.
Codons at which treatment resistance may occur were analyzed further for immunologic selection pressure, as measured by dN/dS ratios and entropy levels for all genotype 5a sequences. Among the NS5B resistance-associated mutations, position 309 was under strong positive selection (dN/dS = 43), while positions 282, 310, 316, 326, 329, and 333 were under strong negative selection pressure (dN/dS < 1). Entropy analysis identified 3 positions from the genotype 5 sequences, with significant entropy levels, including positions 309, 310, and 329, with entropy levels of 0.73, 0.32, and 0.29, respectively.
4. Discussion
HCV is a significant public health issue worldwide; however, data from sub-Saharan Africa are quite limited. Currently, the only antiviral therapies for HCV available in the public sector include peg-IFN and RBV. DAA are not available in the public section and are generally considered cost prohibitive in the private sector. Nonetheless, pre-existing drug mutations could limit the long-term utilization of certain HCV therapies in the future. A recent study (resistance-associated mutations (RAV) in > 1400 full-length HCV sequences deposited in GenBank) observed a high RAV frequency in Africa, but did not analyze genotype 5 due to the very low number of samples available (33).
Given the very limited data on HCV drug resistance in sub-Saharan Africa, particularly in HCV genotype 5 infections, we evaluated the prevalence of certain NS5B drug resistance mutations in treatment naïve South Africans. Several important NS5B substitutions associated with HCV treatment response were detected. For instance, the Q309R mutation was the most frequent resistance mutation detected. Additionally, the majority of genotype 4 sequences had a Q309K substitution, although it is not known whether this represents a bona fide resistance mutation. However, the Q309R mutation is associated with IFN/RBV resistance (22). In vitro studies showed that Q309R mutation is frequent in genotype 1a replicons, with a 0.8-fold increase in EC50% to the potent HCV NS5B non-nucleoside drug TMC647055, while Q309K was found in only 1 replicon of HCV genotype 1b (34). In contrast, the mutations D244N, D310N, S326G, and T329I were absent in all NS5B sequences analyzed. The A333E mutation was detected in 50% of genotype 5a sequences. Further analysis of genotype 5a reference sequences in GenBank indicated that A333E was found in 289 of 357 (81%) of sequences representing this genotype.
Several studies have highlighted the presence of naturally occurring mutations in the NS5B region. An Italian study of 32 patients infected with HCV genotype 1a and 30 patients infected with HCV genotype 1b reported mutations associated with NS5B polymerase in DAA naive patients, although some mutations confer a low level of resistance (25). The NS5B C316N genotype 1b polymorphism was found in all genotype 1b sequences in this study. The C316N mutation resistance has been reported in patients who failed treatment with tegobuvir (35) and is associated with a 26-fold decreased susceptibility to HCV-796 (36). The NS5B S282T, associated with resistance to sofosbuvir (37), and C316Y mutations were not detected in any sequences analyzed. This finding is in agreement with that of other studies, which reported a low prevalence of the S282T mutation (38). To our knowledge, only 1 other study has examined NS5B resistance mutations circulating in South Africa. Among 81 hospital patients and 12 asymptomatic blood donors, Prabdial-Sing et al. identified a single patient infected with genotype 4 that had evidence of possible sofosbuvir resistance (39). However, our finding of additional NS5B resistance mutations may reflect differences in the study populations and/or geographic distribution of samples within South Africa.
The limitations of this study were small sample size, and the short fragment of the NS5B gene analyzed. Nonetheless, this study represents almost the only data on NS5B resistance mutations in South Africa and/or HCV genotype 5 infections. In conclusion, NS5B resistance mutations circulate at low levels in South African patients and could endanger treatment success in the future if not monitored carefully. Future investigations with deep sequence analysis should be conducted to characterize resistance to new therapeutic agents.
