In this study we showed that the number of patients who had obesity increased by up to 21% in the second year after LTx. The prevalence of obesity decreased to pre-transplantation rates during the fifth year. Pre-transplant obesity prevalence was 14.6% and post-transplant prevalence at the 5th year was 4.9%. Patient’s education and medical nutrition therapy may be associated with the improvement. Obesity prevalence at the end of the 5 year follow up was found to be 14.06% with the addition of new subjects after liver transplantation (
Table 3,
Figure 1).
Owing to improvements in surgical techniques, post-operative care and new immunosuppressive treatments, liver transplantation has become the most effective method for acute or chronic end-stage liver disease patients. Since liver transplantation extends the survival of most patients, it necessitates long-term follow-up and care (
1 ). As survival after liver transplantation gets longer, weight gain and obesity have become common health problems for organ recipients. Obesity is seen in approximately 20% of patients after liver transplantation (
6 ) compared to 20–28% in the general population (
9 ,
10). Although immunosuppressive medications used after liver transplantation have many known side effects, immunosuppressives’ effect on weight gain has not yet been clarified (
8). Some researchers state that there is no significant difference, however there is also contrary literature stating otherwise (
4 ,
11 ,
12). We utilized weight gain and BMI measurements similar to studies in the literature that evaluated weight gain after transplantation. We did not use waist and hip circumference measurements due to the fact that, in relation to the severity of pre-transplantation diseases, there might be ascites in the abdominal cavity as a result of cirrhosis. Retrospective data of 226 patients in our study showed an average decrease of 5.7 ± 6.2 kg in the 1st month of post-operative control when compared to the pre-operative period. This situation can be explained by ascites and pretibial edema in patients before liver transplantation. Since patients’ mean dry weights were not measured, we can also speak of a relative weight loss due to drainage of ascites from the peritoneal cavity after the operation. In addition to this, pre-operative time spent in intensive care units, emotional status of the patients, and insufficient nourishment caused by medications may be important factors in post-operative weight loss. The patients who used a steroid for six months showed a mean weight gain of 4.71 ± 5.75 kg vs. 2.77 ± 6.98 kg for the non-steroid group of patients. The difference between these 2 groups was statistically significant (P = 0.03). In a prospective study by Richards et al., in which 597 liver transplantation patients were evaluated for weight change, a rapid weight gain was reported in the first year, 5 kg in the second year, and 10 kg in the third year (
4 ). The first month’s BMI measurement of our patients after liver transplantation was 23.7 ± 3.6 kg/m², significantly increasing to 26.2 ± 4.0 kg/m² in the following year. 17.6% of patients included in the study developed obesity 2 years after transplantation. Likewise, 21.6% of the non-obese patients in the study conducted by Everhart et al. developed obesity 2 years after transplantation (
11 ). Thus, our findings were similar to the studies in the literature (
6 ,
11 ). Various studies state that obesity is seen less often in patients using tacrolimus than in patients using cyclosporine after liver transplantation (
13 ). Although some studies relate CsA use directly to obesity development (
4 ,
14 ), other studies do not accept this theory (
15 ,
16 ). In a study by Canzanello et al, 46% of patients using CsA developed obesity compared to 27% in TAC users (
17 ). The fact that more CsA users developed obesity than TAC users was probably because TAC users needed corticosteroids more (
7 ). Most of the patients in our study used TAC-based (73.8%) or CsA-based (24.7%) immunosuppressive treatments. The prevalence of MMF and steroid treatments in addition to calcineurin inhibitors was 88.0% and 95.5%, respectively. Among patients who were not obese (BMI < 30 kg/m²) at the time of liver transplantation and used CNI, 18.2% developed obesity. In contrary to the literature, no statistically significant difference in mean weight gain was found between TAC users and CsA users (
12 ). There was also no significant difference in development of obesity between the patients using tacrolimus and cyclosporine (17.9% vs. 19.4%, P = 0.07). Multivariate analysis showed that TAC, sirolimus and CsA were negatively associated with the development of obesity (P < 0.001, P < 0.001 and P < 0.001).
In our study we showed that age and gender were independent variables that predicted the development of obesity. (P = 0.002 and P = 0.013). Subjects with pre-transplantation obesity had 4.37 times higher risk of post-transplantation obesity. Therefore subjects with pre-transplantation obesity should be strictly followed. Regular evaluation of metabolic parameters and initiation of medical nutrition therapy can be beneficial in the long term. In multivariate analysis, when the pre-transplantation obese group was excluded, it was demonstrated that age, gender, Tac, CsA ve sirolimus significantly predicted obesity. In this group of subjects, risk of developing obesity was found to be 2.87 times higher in men than in women. Remaining factors had weak effects on obesity. Therefore, male subjects should be evaluated strictly in terms of obesity after transplantation. Although some researchers state that immunosuppressives, especially corticosteroids, are responsible for weight gain and obesity development after transplantation (
11,
17), other researchers do not support this view (
4,
18). The common opinion is that the appetizing effect of steroids contributes to weight gain (
19). The study of Wawrzynowicz et al. on 75 patients who had liver transplantation showed weight gain of 6.1 kg in the first 6 months after transplantation and a dynamic weight gain occurred in the first year (
8). With regards to weight gain, there was no significant difference between steroid users and non-users. Furthermore, the same study did not identify a significant weight gain difference between use of cyclosporine and tacrolimus. Contrary to the study of Wawrzynowicz et al., our study identified an average increase of 4.71 kg in the body weight of the group who used a steroid for 6 months and 2.77 kg in the group who did not use a steroid (P = 0.03). Furthermore, a significant increase in the body weight has persisted between the two groups in the first year after liver transplantation (P = 0.02). On the other hand, some studies state that weight gain continues even though steroid use is decreased (
18). The retrospective data of our patients showed that among the patients who developed obesity after transplantation, 3 (7.5%) developed de-novo DM, 8 (20%) developed HT, and 1 (2.5%) developed HL after transplantation. Although there are publications stating that tacrolimus is more diabetogenic than cyclosporine (
20), our study did not find a significant difference regarding newly developed diabetes mellitus, hypertension and hyperlipidemia due to TAC and CsA use (P = 0.30). The study by Sheiner et al. on 139 liver transplantation patients did not observe an effect of CNIs on new diabetes development; the same publication found that the rate of weight gain and hypercholesterolemia due to immunosuppressive treatment was similar to that of the general population (
12). The study by Becker et al. which compared tacrolimus/daclizumab and tacrolimus/MMF immunosuppressive treatments stated that not using a steroid decreased de-novo diabetes development and insulin use after transplantation and the patients did not gain weight (
21). Another factor in obesity development after transplantation is the changes in nourishment. Termination of the limited dietary program before transplantation, the patient’s emotional status, and the appetizing effect of corticosteroids contribute to this. The effect of MMF treatment on obesity was not suitable for statistical evaluation, as most of the patients (88%) received this treatment (in addition to CNI treatment) and there were only a few patients whom we could exclude. There are some limitations in our study; the patient population was relatively small, our study was retrospective in nature and all of the patients were not followed up throughout the five years. In conclusion, our study showed that the prevalence of obesity in patients with liver transplantation is 21% and 14% at the end of the second year and the fifth year, respectively. Non-corticoid immunosuppressive medications (CNI, mTOR inhibitors, MMF) did not have a significant effect on weight gain and obesity development. The reason why there was no significant difference between TAC and CsA with regards to weight gain may be explained by the fact that our patients who used CNI in the first years after liver transplantation received steroid treatment as well. Along with corticosteroid treatments in the first months, we think that a sedentary lifestyle, recovering hepatic function, regained appetite, and improved nourishment also play a role in weight gain and obesity.