This was the ļ¬rst study demonstrating the association between polymorphisms of promoter genes of IL-10 (-592 A/C, -819 T/C, -1082 A/G) and susceptibility to HBV in Iranian populations. Our strongest findings were among variants of IL-10, especially the SNP 1082 (A/G; rs1800896), which has a strong association in this sample of Iranian population. There was also an association between CCG haplotype of IL-10 and HBV infection outcome.
HBV and HCV infected individuals are living with chronic liver disease with different severity such as hepatocytes lesions, liver cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) (
34).
It is believed that host genetic factors relating to genetic polymorphisms are responsible for clinical outcomes of disease (
25,
28,
35). Also differences in the susceptibility to disease can be attributed to the virulence of an organism.
There was evidence that HBV infection outcome was influenced by SNP variants of the cytokines. Cytokine production differs among Individuals. This is associated with SNPs in the regulatory regions of cytokine genes (
36).
IL-10 is produced by lymphocytes and monocytes and the level of its production determines immune regulation and plays an important role in hepatitis pathogenesis. Expression of IL-10 is genetically controlled. Studies have shown that
IL-10 gene polymorphism is a key player in differential expression of IL-10 and would affect bodyās immune response to HBV and susceptibility to HBV. Therefore, these polymorphisms can cause individually differences in immune response and lead to different host immune function (
19,
37,
38). Therefore, IL-10 polymorphism determination is important for predicting susceptibility to HBV infection.
Although IL-10 variants have been associated with hepatitis C recovery (
39), based on our researches, this is the first finding in Iran, since IL-10 variants have not been implicated with HBV pathogenesis before. In HCV infection some studies on various ethnic groups deny a positive association and others indicate such a link (
26,
40,
41).
This study demonstrated a significant association between the IL-10 -1082 A/G polymorphism and HBV infection susceptibility in a sample of Iranian population. The other IL-10 polymorphisms were not associated with HBV infection.
In our study, only -1082 G allele was signiļ¬cantly represented in HBV patients. Chronic liver disease raises inflammatory and anti-inflammatory responses. These events are responsible for high IL-10 levels. Previous in-vitro studies showed that the -1082 G allele corresponds to higher IL-10 protein expression. Moreover, proinflammatory IL-10 levels increased with HBV infection progression, as compared to controls. However, the -1082 GG, AG and AA genotypes are related to high, intermediate and low IL-10 production in patients with HBV, respectively (
19). The -1082 AG and GG genotypes are associated with HBV risk and can increase susceptibility to HBV in subjects. On the other hand, increased levels of IL-10 have been shown in chronic HBV patients (
19), indicating that individuals carrying -1082 G allele have a risk of HBV infection. Our findings indicated that GG and AG genotypes were more prevalent in patients in comparison to healthy subjects. These results were in accordance with those reported by Turner et al., Eskdale et al. and Truelove et al. (
19,
24,
42). They showed that susceptibility to HBV increases in patients with G allele and other studies in India (
43) and Chinese (
44) populations did not report the same result. In these populations, IL-10 -1082 A/G polymorphism was not related to chronic HBV infection.
Recently Baghi et al. (
45) reported that IL10 promoter gene polymorphisms predisposed cirrhosis in infected hepatitis B patients. They showed that the -592A/C, -819T/C polymorphisms and CCG/ATA haplotype of the
IL-10 gene promoter were significantly more common in patients with HBV related cirrhosis. Earlier, Sofian et al. (
46) revealed that genotypes and haplotypes of
IL-10 gene promoter (-1082,-819,-592) were not significantly different among controls and chronic HBV patients. They did not find any correlation between
IL-10 gene promoter polymorphism and HBV infection; however, their study size was relatively small compared to our study.
These different ļ¬ndings are related to sample size of studied populations and/or different ethnical backgrounds. Our study was conducted in south-east of Iran. In this area, diversity of the resident population is higher than other parts of Iran and this could be the reason of these discrepancies in various studies.
However in Asian population the
-1082GG genotype was rarely found (
32,
47,
48). In this study, analysis of genotypes showed that subjects with -1082GG are susceptible to HBV compared to the
-1082 AA genotype. In this regard, Reuses et al. noted that the -1082 GG allele produces higher levels of IL-10, which compromises immune response to infection (
20).
In this study, it may indicate complexity of the immune response in humans. Also this may have been due to low number of subjects. By the way, analysis of this polymorphism in HBV infection has shown conflicting findings (
28,
29,
32,
37).
It seems that IL10 variations have an important role in HBV infection. Shin et al. indicated that IL-10 -592C allele (high IL-10 producer) accelerates chronic HBV infection (
49). In contrast, Cheong et al. showed that individuals with IL-10 -592A allele (low IL-10 producer) had an increased susceptibility to HBV (
29). Also studies indicated that IL-10 -592AA genotype exerts a protective effect against HBV infection (
19). Peng et al. showed that IL-10 intermediate producer genotypes or haplotypes cause HBeAg seroconversions in patients (
28).
We did not find any significant association between IL-10 alleles, -592 A/C and -819 T/C or genotypes and susceptibility to HBV infection in patients compared to the healthy control subjects. It shows that -592 A/C and -819 T/C do not influence susceptibility to HBV infection. These two polymorphisms are in linkage disequilibrium. It means that polymorphisms at position -592 and -819 have no independent effect on IL-10 functions. It is believed that IL-10 production is independent from -592A/C and -819T/C polymorphisms (
19).
In field of polymorphisms at position -592 and -819, our results were in agreement with previous studies in Chinese (
32,
44) and Indian (
43) populations. In Chinese researches the IL-10-592 A/C polymorphisms did not differ significantly between HBV carriers and healthy volunteers groups. However, the capacity for IL-10 production depends on genetic polymorphisms and polymorphism at position -592 of the candidate gene in patients with HBV does not emerge as a probable biomarker for determining the disease. In addition, no significant differences were detected between Indian HBV patients and healthy controls in distributions of
IL-10 genotype at the ā592, ā819 and ā1082 positions. However, according to the odds ratio it seems that heterozygosity of genotypes ā592 A/C and ā819 T/C is associated with liver chronicity and increased risk of persistent infection.
Conversely, Afzal et al. (
27) reported that in Pakistani population, IL-10 -819 T/C and -592 A/C promoter polymorphism, at the allele level but not in genotype distribution, were signiļ¬cantly different in patients with hepatitis in comparison with healthy controls. In this regard we did not see any significant differences in neither alleles nor genotypes frequencies. Our results suggested lack of association of IL-10 -819 T/C and -592 A/C alleles as well as genotypes with HBV.
Wu et al. also showed that IL-10 -1082 GG genotype is associated with lower HBV viral load in comparison to patients with A allele (
50). Gao et al. reported that IL-10-592 and IL-10-1082 polymorphisms are not different at the allele level between cases and control (
32). A meta-analysis in 2010 indicated that IL-10-1082 polymorphism was not related to HBV infection in Asia (
51). In another study conducted by Zhang et al. no significant differences were discovered in
IL-10 gene promoter polymorphisms among chronic HBV patients and controls. But their study indicated that -592AA and -819TT genotypes were more prevalent in chronic HBV patients (
52).
Consequently, we can obtain a suggestive evidence of association with hepatitis B for IL-10-1082 promoter polymorphism at the allele and genotype distribution, but not for IL-10-592 and -819. Some disagreements between these studies indicate the possible impact of genetic background of different populations. These studies suggest that different IL-10 gene polymorphisms can affect cytokine responses, which may in turn influence susceptibility to HBV infection.
Analysis of haplotype could explain the effect of these three SNPs on susceptibility to HBV. In previous studies, the CCG haplotype was associated with increased IL-10 production compared with the ATA and CCA haplotypes (
19). In the current study, IL-10 haplotype distribution indicated that the frequency of the CCG haplotype among HBV patients was higher than that of healthy subjects.
Our findings were in agreement with the results reported by Turner (
19). He indicated that the CCG haplotype frequency in hepatitis cases was higher than the controls. Nonetheless, Afzal et al. indicated significant differences between patients and controls regarding ATG and CCA haplotypes (
27). Also in some studies from Caucasian, Italy and Japan, IL-10 haplotypes were not distributed differently between controls and patients (
47,
49,
53). It may be due to different ethnicity background of those populations. When we analyzed haplotypes, individuals with IL-10/CCG haplotype were genetically predisposed to develop HBV. In addition, IL-10/ATA haplotype was more common in controls than patients. It means that individuals with this genetic variation are less likely to develop HBV and subjects with haplotypes having the G allele are in increased risk of HBV infection. On the other hand, several factors such as sample size, patientsā selection and different gene-gene interactions can cause conflicting results of these studies.
It seems that different cultural backgrounds such as decreasing body mass index and smoking may have effects on decreased IL-10 production (
20). Moreover, epidemiological and geographical factors can cause conflicting results. Study conditions (such as number and characteristics of subjects and HBV genotype variations) can affect the results as well.
In summary, our study showed that
IL-10 gene polymorphism has an influence on HBV infection. The polymorphism of IL-10 -1082 showed a significant association with susceptibility to chronic HBV. The IL-10 -1082 AG and GG were associated with increased risk of persistent HBV. IL-10 polymorphism appeared to play an essential role in human HBV susceptibility to infection. Some of our results are in agreement with earlier publications on IL-10 promoter polymorphism and HBV infection. Other observations from this study are contrary to previous findings in other populations. There are different IL-10 binding receptors and homologues to IL-10 (
54). So it is difficult to specify the real effect of genetic polymorphisms on disease susceptibility. These phenomena can affect the association between IL-10 promoter polymorphisms and HBV infection. Further researches on functional implications of IL10, specifically regarding immune response to HBV, are warranted. Moreover, we believe that our findings may stimulate further investigations on a larger size to assess the association of these polymorphisms in HBV patients.