Chondromyxoid Fibroma of Two Cervical Vertebrae with Involvement of Surrounding Soft Tissue: Radiologic Diagnostic Dilemma

1. Introduction

Chondromyxoid fibroma (CMF) is a rare benign cartilaginous neoplasm, and it accounts for less than 1% of all bone tumors. There is no gender predilection, but in some of the published case series, a male tendency has been reported (1-10). It occurs mainly in the second and third decades, and the majority occurs before the age of 30 years (2). The most common locations are the upper third of the tibia, small tubular bones of the foot, the distal femur and pelvis (3, 4). Involvement of the vertebral column is rare, especially in the cervical region. In general, CMFs originate from the metaphyseal region of the long bones. Literature reviews have shown that CMF is very rare in the cervical region, and only less than 11 cases have been reported up to now (1, 5-8). CMF of the cervical spine may present with unusual radiological findings and pose a diagnostic dilemma; therefore, we first report our case and then briefly discuss its radiological, histopathological and clinical characteristics.

2. Case Presentation

A 36-year-old woman came to the neurosurgery clinic with a one-year history of neck pain and semi-lateral radicular pain in her right hand. Her past medical history was unremarkable. On ultrasound examination, there was a hypo-echoic oval mass-like lesion located on the right side of the C3 and C4 vertebrae and adjacent subcutaneous soft tissue, measuring 1.2 × 3.6 × 1.6 cm. The ultrasound possible differential diagnosis was right paravertebral muscle soft tissue lesion due to inflammatory or neoplastic origins. A lateral plain x-ray of the neck revealed an ill-defined hypoattenuated area within the deep soft tissue of the posterior aspect of the C3 and C4 vertebrae just posterior to the related spinous process without bony erosion, demineralization, foreign body, or soft-tissue calcification. Irregularity and possible erosion in the spinous process of C5 of the cervical vertebrae was seen (Figure 1).

A 36-year-old woman with neck pain and semi-lateral radicular pain in the right hand. A lateral plain x-ray of the neck reveals an ill-defined hypoattenuated area adjacent to the deep soft tissue of the posterior aspect of the C3 and C4 vertebrae, just posterior to the related spinous process and some irregularity or possible erosion in the spinous process of fifth cervical vertebra.

Figure 1.

A 36-year-old woman with neck pain and semi-lateral radicular pain in the right hand. A lateral plain x-ray of the neck reveals an ill-defined hypoattenuated area adjacent to the deep soft tissue of the posterior aspect of the C3 and C4 vertebrae, just posterior to the related spinous process and some irregularity or possible erosion in the spinous process of fifth cervical vertebra.

On Doppler ultrasound, there was no blood flow detected and the mass was reported as a hypo-vascular lesion. On magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), a well-defined encapsulated 2.6 × 2 × 1.8 cm mass lesion emanating from the soft tissue of the paravertebral neck was detected that abutted the spinous process and lamina of the posterior neural arc of the C3 and C4 vertebrae and appeared to be low signal intensity on the T1 weighted imaging (T1W1) (Figure 2). The lesion was seen as a target shaped lesion with a centrally hypo-intense and peripherally mild hyper-intense thick rim and surrounding edema on T2WI (Figure 3). On post-contrast T1WI, considerable enhancement of the peripheral thick rim and adjacent posterior soft tissues of C3 and C4 vertebrae were presented (Figure 4). The patient underwent surgical resection, and a frozen section study was requested. The specimen received for frozen section consisted of one piece of cream colored tissue measuring 3 × 2 cm. Histopathological examination revealed a lobulated tumoral lesion composed of fibromyxoid connective tissue admixed with small islands of cartilaginous tissue and areas of calcification, so the frozen section suggested a benign lesion. The received specimen for permanent diagnosis consisted of multiple pieces of brownish colored tissues altogether measuring 4 × 3 cm. Histopathological examination revealed a tumoral lesion composed of proliferated chondrocytes, admixed with fibromyxoid connective tissues, and scattered osteoclast-like multinucleated giant cells (Figure 5 A, 5B). Mature bone trabeculae rimmed by osteoblasts with areas of calcification were also detected. The final diagnosis was CMF of the posterior elements of the cervical bones with extension to the adjacent soft tissue. The patient received no other treatment and after two years of surgery, she has not suffered from any problem related to the lesion in her neck area and no recurrence was reported.

A well-defined encapsulated mass lesion emanating from the soft tissue of the paravertebral neck abutting spinous process and lamina of the posterior neural arc of the C3 and C4 vertebrae on sagittal T1 weighted MRI. The mass showed low signal intensity on sagittal T1WI.

Figure 2.

A well-defined encapsulated mass lesion emanating from the soft tissue of the paravertebral neck abutting spinous process and lamina of the posterior neural arc of the C3 and C4 vertebrae on sagittal T1 weighted MRI. The mass showed low signal intensity on sagittal T1WI.

A target shaped lesion, central hypointense and peripheral mild hyperintence thick rim with surrounding edema located on the mid-line of the neck around C3 and C4 vertebrae on sagittal T2WI is seen.

Figure 3.

A target shaped lesion, central hypointense and peripheral mild hyperintence thick rim with surrounding edema located on the mid-line of the neck around C3 and C4 vertebrae on sagittal T2WI is seen.

Coronal post contrast T1WI shows considerable enhancement of the peripheral thick rim and adjacent posterior soft tissues of the C3 and C4 vertebrae.

Figure 4.

Coronal post contrast T1WI shows considerable enhancement of the peripheral thick rim and adjacent posterior soft tissues of the C3 and C4 vertebrae.

A and B, Histopathological examination shows chondroid tissue admixed with fibroblasts and scanty multinucleated giant cells (H & E staining, Magnification, ×200 and ×400) spinous process of fifth cervical vertebra.

Figure 5.

A and B, Histopathological examination shows chondroid tissue admixed with fibroblasts and scanty multinucleated giant cells (H & E staining, Magnification, ×200 and ×400) spinous process of fifth cervical vertebra.

3. Discussion

CMFs are extremely rare benign cartilaginous bone neoplasms that were initially described by Jaffe and Lichtenstein in 1948 (10). There is no gender predilection, but in some of the published case series, higher numbers of males have been reported. It usually occurs in the second or third decades and the majority appears before the age of 30 years. Most of the CMFs are located in the metaphyseal region of the long bones. One third of them forms in the tibia, small tubular bones of foot, and the distal femur and pelvis (1-12). CMFs in the vertebral columns are rare, especially in the cervical region and related soft tissue vicinity. Lopez et al. reported CMF of the cervical spine in a 20-year-old man with neck pain that was located in the body of the C2 vertebra. X-ray showed a lytic lesion in the C2 body that causes instability of the craniocervical vertebra without extension into the soft tissue (5). Our case was an adult female who had suffered from a long history of neck pain and there was an imperceptible lump on an x-ray in the right paravertebral soft tissue. Although the radiological findings were not diagnostic for CMF, it originated from the lamina and spinous processes of the cervical bones and extended into the adjacent soft tissue. Spinal CMF was first reported by Benson and Bass (1). Radiological features are not characteristic, but may present as a lobulated, eccentric radiolucent lesion with no periosteal reaction, and in all of the patients, geographic bone destruction is visible. The margin of the CMF is sclerotic, and defined with pseudotrabeculation in 57% of the cases, and matrix calcification is seen in about 12.5% of the cases (11). MRI features of CMF of vertebral column are not specific, but the helpful features are the peripheral intermediate signal band, central high signal intensity on T2-WI, and peripheral nodular enhancement or central non-enhancing focus on contrast-enhanced T1-WI (12). In addition, a doughnut sign is seen in bone scans of CMFs; however, this is a non-specific finding because it may be found in other bone tumors (11, 12). Other benign tumors, such as aneurysmal bone cyst, giant cell tumor, enchondroma, non-ossifying fibroma and chondroblastoma could be listed in the differential diagnoses. In long bones, CMF originates from the metaphysis close to the physis, and it may also extend into the epiphysis or diaphysis. Furthermore, it usually appears as an eccentric, oval shape lesion. In small bones, a CMF may involve the diaphysis, metaphysis, and epiphysis (1). The preferred imaging study is conventional radiography with its specific characteristics composed of a bubbly cystic appearance, but a computed tomography (CT) scan displays a sclerotic calcification margin and trabeculation better than conventional radiography (11). In our case, a plain X-ray showed a barely discernible ill-defined soft-tissue density within the deep soft tissues of the posterior aspect of the C3 and C4 vertebrae just posterior to the related spinous process without characteristic features of CMF in the vertebral bones. CMFs have different tissue components with a heterogeneous appearance on MRI studies. For example, chondroid and myxoid tissues create an intermediate to high signal on proton-density and T2-WI or low signal on T1-WI (12). CMFs show a high accumulation of fluorodeoxyglucose in positron emission tomography (PET) scan, but we did not perform this study for our patient. The most common site of vertebral column involvement by CMF is in the thoracic region, with a predilection for the posterior neural arc (4). Chondrosarcoma, osteoblastoma, aneurysmal bone cyst, giant cell tumor of the bone, metastasis, multiple myeloma, and collapsed hemangioma of the vertebral bodies are the most common differential diagnoses in radiological investigations. Jonathan et al. reported CMF in the seventh cervical vertebra of a 35-year-old man, in whom X-ray, MRI and bone scans, suggested an aneurysmal bone cyst or a giant cell tumor (1). Two adjacent vertebral bone involvements, especially in the cervical vertebrae have not been reported yet. Bruder et al. reported a case of CMF in two thoracic vertebrae that originated from vertebral bodies, but our case was CMF in two cervical vertebrae with involvement of the laminas and spinous processes (13). The symptoms of this benign tumor seem to be progressive longstanding pain, swelling, and motion restriction of the affected limb (1-8). Histopathologically, the tumor is composed of chondroid, myxoid, and fibrous connective tissue, which are arranged in a lobular pattern. Scattered osteoclast-like multinucleated giant cells are occasionally seen inside the tumor, especially at the periphery. Areas of calcification are also present in some cases. Mitotic figures are rare or absent (10). The main differential diagnosis of CMF from chondrosarcoma histologically is the sharp borders of the lobules and also radiologic studies which could help to make the correct diagnosis (11). En bloc excision of the tumor is the treatment of choice, but recurrences after curettage have been reported. Our case has not had any recurrence after the excision.

Although CMF is a rare benign bone tumor, involvement of the vertebral column especially the cervical vertebrae is very rare, but we listed it in the differential diagnosis despite the unusual soft tissue extension. Conventional radiology with MRI and PET scan could give us better diagnostic information.