Although
C. albicans is the main causative agent of mucocutaneous and IC infections, those caused by other common NAC species are also on the rise. Of note, clinical outcomes indicate that non-
albicans species are generally more resistant to antifungal agents than
C. albicans (
17). Triazoles are the drugs of choice for the treatment and prevention of
Candida infections. It has been reported that the resistance rate of
C. tropicalis to the triazoles fluconazole and voriconazole exceeds 20%, the resistance rate of
C. glabrata to voriconazole is close to 50% in recent years, the resistance rate of
C. albicans to triazole antifungal drugs is approximately 5 - 10%, and innate fluconazole resistance has been identified in
C. krusei (
5,
18). Rapid and accurate identification of
Candida species is critical for antifungal infection treatment. The conventional culture method is the gold standard for
Candida identification, but its time-consuming nature has always been a major problem in clinical applications (
5).
The
Candida chromogenic culture method is commonly used in clinical examination, in which the tested strains are grown on a chromogenic medium with visible colonies after 24 - 48 hours (
19). Therefore, empirical antifungal therapy is still very common. The main purpose of this study was to develop a new method that would retain the advantages of the culture method while enriching the samples through short-term culture, combined with dual-target melting analysis to efficiently differentiate common
Candida species, thus reducing the time needed to initiate targeted treatment for patients with severe candidiasis. There was no need for prolonged incubation of samples with the micro-level template requirements of a PCR-based assay. This research demonstrated a method in which yeast samples were cultured on a microporous membrane pre-coated SDA plate for up to 10 hours, and then the membrane was transferred to an indicator plate containing thiazolyl blue. As shown in
Figure 2, it took approximately 8 to 10 hours for the
Candida isolates from different parts of the body to enter the log phase. The detection time did not vary significantly according to the different strain sources. The colonies appeared dark blue within 3 minutes.
The coloring substance thiazolyl blue interacted with the succinate dehydrogenase in the yeast to produce dark-blue formazan, which colored the colonies and improved the sensitivity for visual inspection (
Figure 3). Furthermore, the results of this research suggested that the thiazolyl blue-stained colonies did not affect the release of template DNA during lysis. However, to reduce the impact of the lysate components on subsequent real-time PCR, the lysate should be diluted no less than 10 times. The nutritional status of
Candida in the membrane-based culture was consistent with conventional SDA culture. When cultured with conventional SDA for the first 10 hours of growth, the generated colonies were small, and the contrast between the natural white colonies and the light-colored background of the culture medium was correspondingly low, making it difficult to distinguish colonies by visual inspection. When using a membrane-based culture plate combined with thiazolyl blue, the contrast between the dark blue-stained colonies and the white background of the membrane was significantly increased, making it convenient for observation by the naked eye. After culturing for 10 hours, the colonies were sufficiently large for observation, even though they were grown on a conventional SDA plate.
Membrane-based cultivation was no longer necessary at this point. It can be seen that the advantage of the membrane-based culture lies in the early observation and early sampling of the
Candida culture. In this study, a visible colony was selected and used in the next process, real-time PCR-based melting analysis and the entire detection time was found to be 12 hours shorter than the conventional culture method. If using a low-powered microscope combined with micromanipulation, it is possible to find and pick dark-blue colonies at an even earlier time point, and this research approach is expected to further reduce the overall time required and generate higher predictive power than the conventional culture method. The membrane-based culture involved in this research was reported previously for the application of bacterial colony counting, but with that study, a special commercial pre-coated film plate was needed. Unlike the previously reported study, in this study, a common microporous membrane was added to the surface of an ordinary SDA plate, which can significantly reduce the cost. In addition, microbial identification after colony counting was not included in the previous study (
11).
It is well known that the clinical treatment of
Candida infection, especially severe infection, is a race against time, and the results of this study are undoubtedly of great significance for improving the current situation in this regard. Inappropriate empiric therapy can be minimized through early identification of
Candida species. To shorten the overall
Candida identification cycle, this research integrated short-term membrane-based cultivation and convenient real-time PCR. As shown in previous studies, real-time PCR followed by melting analysis simplifies PCR-based technologies, avoids external nucleic acid contamination and postprocessing, such as electrophoresis or enzymatic digestion, and enables the identification of amplicons directly by specific melting peaks (
20-
23).
The versatility and specificity of primers are very critical in real-time PCR-based melting analysis, and therefore primers in this research were selected in the coding region of the Candida ribosomal DNA gene, in which the sequence is both conserved and diverse. Universal primer amplicons from different Candida species may have similar lengths but most likely have significantly different Tm values due to the differing GC content. It was also the original intention of this study to combine specific melting peaks with specific Tm values to distinguish different common Candida species.
A single primer set may be difficult to judge accurately due to less pronounced differences among individual primers or possible variations in T
m values between samples in the melting analysis. This research demonstrated that dual-target PCR using two sets of specific
Candida primers improved the resolution of differentiation for the common
Candida species. The purpose of using the primer set CALB was similar to previous reports (
14,
24), which was the identification of
C. albicans from NAC species. It was originally designed as a species-specific primer set to identify
C. albicans by targeting the 5.8S ribosomal DNA region (
14,
15). Although the primer set CALB was used for the analysis of
Candida species in a recent study (
25), there is no clear report on the melting analysis of the amplicons for each species, except for the T
m value of
C. albicans. In this research, it was found that the melting peak (T
m = 85.75°C) of the primer set CALB against
C. albicans was similar to that described in a previous study (
15) and was either clearly distinguished from the T
m values of the other three
Candida species detected or had a higher fluorescence intensity due to a better match between the primers and target. In addition to the primer set CALB, the primer set CAND was used for further identification of NAC species, which has been used as a set of pan-
Candida primers to identify
Candida species in previous studies (
16).
Based on the
Candida nucleotide sequences published on the
NCBI website, the PCR product size of
C. albicans,
C. tropicalis,
C. glabrata, and
C. krusei amplified by primer set CAND is 328 bp, 318 bp, 407 bp, and 336 bp, respectively. The corresponding GC content is 54.27%, 46.64%, 49.63%, and 56.85%, which matches the results of the melting temperature analysis following real-time PCR of the four
Candida strains in the present research. Using the primer set CAND to distinguish
Candida species in this study; we obtained T
m values that were similar to previous studies (
14); however, there were also small T
m value differences in each species, which may be due to slight changes in gene sequences caused by species phylogeny and evolution (
26,
27). Although the T
m values generated by primer set CAND for
C. albicans and
C. glabrata differed only slightly from each other (approximately 1°C), the distinction of each strain increased notably when combined with the melting peak using the primer set CALB (
Figure 4 and
Table 4).
Interestingly, in the 72 clinical isolates tested here, two Candida isolates were initially identified as C. glabrata by the commercial chromogenic media. However, they showed a different melting peak position from that of the C. glabrata reference strain in the melting analysis of this research. After DNA sequencing, the two strains were confirmed as C. parapsilosis. C. glabrata and C. parapsilosis produce similarly colored cultures when grown on chromogenic media, which can make it difficult to distinguish between the two strains. This work may improve the resolution of Candida species differentiation through confirmation by dual-target detection.
5.1. Conclusions
The integrated technique established here, which utilized short-term membrane-based cultivation combined with dual-target melting analysis, identified common Candida species more rapidly and accurately than other culture-based methods. It is expected to retain the advantages of the culture methods and improve upon their weaknesses while reducing the time needed to initiate targeted treatment of patients with severe candidiasis.