Animal models play an essential role in clarifying the pathophysiological mechanism of NAFLD. Models that mimic the histopathology and pathophysiology of every stage of human NAFLD can provide a better understanding of its pathogenesis and progression. Nevertheless, there are no accurate animal models representing the complete disease spectrum in a suitable timeframe, because the indices of NAFLD vary from animals to animals.
In this regard, Jensen et al. claimed that one of the reasons for the non-reproducibility and insignificance of comparisons in preclinical studies of NAFLD can be possible changes in sampling and non-standard sample sites (
15-
17). The present study proposed a model of NAFLD in Wistar rats by using CCL
4, olive oil, and fructose for six weeks. We also studied differences in body weight, food intake, liver function tests, and serum biochemical parameters between the groups and within the groups in three time intervals.
Considering the changes in the serum levels of biochemical parameters (e.g., increased ALT and AST as serum markers of liver damage), as well as changes observed in the H&E staining of liver tissues, induction of NAFLD can be confirmed in the intervention group compared to the healthy controls. Also, since the gold standard method for the diagnosis and evaluation of NAFLD is pathology, by measuring hepatocyte indices, such as hepatocyte ballooning, lobular inflammation, and steatosis, besides calculating the NAS, NAFLD induction can be ensured. Generally, an optimal model has a higher level of steatosis and NAS.
Unlike previous studies which added fructose to drinking water (with ad libitum access of the animals), fructose in the present study was administered at a specific amount by intragastric gavage to eliminate the bias of excess calorie (
18). The present results showed that treatment with 0.1 mL/kg of 25% (v/v) CCl
4 solution in olive oil, along with 20% fructose/day for six weeks, resulted in simple steatosis, moderate activity of NAFLD, and a significant increase in the serum levels of TG, TC, LDL, and GGT. Recent studies have suggested that in male Wistar rats, consumption of drinking water with 20% fructose for six weeks led to the development of macrovesicular hepatic steatosis, increased body weight, and increased serum TG levels, without increasing TC or transaminase levels (
18,
19). Another study showed that 20% fructose for 16 weeks resulted in microvesicular steatosis in Wistar rats and increased their body weight, without increasing the serum TG and transaminase levels (
20). It is worth mentioning that 20% fructose alone, if administered ad libitum, cannot produce the NAFLD phenotype.
CCl
4 is one of the chemical factors, commonly used to induce NAFLD. It is also considered to be an extremely toxic chemical agent (
21). Nevertheless, the use of CCl
4 alone induces fibrosis, not obesity or insulin resistance. Therefore, it is not an ideal model of NAFLD, and it is often combined with another diet when modeling NAFLD (
15,
22). CCl
4 is usually dissolved in vegetable oils and intraperitoneally injected into rats at a dose of 0.2 - 2 mL/kg over 6 - 12 weeks (
23). CCl
4, by producing activated oxygen-free radicals, destroys the hepatocellular structure and function. The peritoneal injection and intragastric administration of CCl
4 every two weeks can induce extensive liver damage and increase the levels of transaminase and TG (
24,
25) Although these models can easily and quickly cause fatty liver, this type of treatment increases the risk of mortality due to poisoning. Besides, the pathogenesis, histomorphological changes, and progression of disease in models are different from those of the human fatty liver (
22).
In the present study, to reduce CCl4 toxicity, we first developed an experimental model of NAFLD by using CCl4 at a dose of 0.1 mL/kg, but in two proportions of 25% (C1) and 16.66% (C2), dissolved in olive oil; we compared the results with a control diet. In the sixth week of the intervention, the increase in body weight and food intake was similar in the C1 and C2 groups as compared to the control group. An increase in liver enzymes and TC was also observed following the intraperitoneal injection of CCl4 in the C1 group. Besides, treatment with 0.1 mL/kg of 25% (v/v) CCl4 solution in olive oil resulted in the marked activity of NAFLD, steatosis, and inflammation, while steatosis was not observed with 16.66% (v/v) CCl4.
CCl
4, by producing activated oxygen-free radicals and covalent binding of these metabolites to the cell components, increases the synthesis of lipids and decreases their transport from hepatocytes, because it significantly inhibits the secretion of VLDL- and HDL-associated triglycerides and cholesterol esters (
26); this can result in steatosis or fatty liver (
27). The present results indicated that 0.1 mL/kg of 25% (v/v) CCl4 dissolved in olive oil could be used in combination with other diets for six weeks to induce NAFLD in Wistar rats.
Finally, to induce NAFLD, we used the following models: 12.5% fructose in combination with 12.5% olive oil (FF); 0.1 mL/kg of 25% (v/v) CCl
4 dissolved in olive oil in combination with 45% fructose and 35% olive oil (FFC1); and 0.1 ml/kg of 25% (v/v) CCl
4 solution in olive oil in combination with 20% fructose (FC1). In the sixth week of the intervention, changes in body weight, food intake, liver enzymes, and lipid profile were similar in the FF and FFC1 groups compared to the control group. Mild steatosis was observed in the FF and FFC1 groups. On the other hand, in the FC1 group, the rats showed significant differences in body weight and food intake compared to the control and C1 groups. The decrease in food intake in the FC1 group compared to the control group was due to increased calorie intake from fructose consumption; these results are consistent with previous studies (
19).
Moreover, the FC1 group showed a significant increase in the serum levels of TG, TC, LDL-C, and GGT, while the FF group showed a significant decrease in HDL-C compared to the FC1 and FF groups. The increase in serum lipids in the FC1 group can be related to the ability of fructose to stimulate de novo lipogenesis, because fructose may directly stimulate lipogenic transcriptional factors, including sterol regulatory element-binding protein 1 (SREBP1c) and carbohydrate response element binding protein (ChREBP) in the liver, activating every stage of de novo lipogenesis (
28). In the FC1 group, steatosis was also found by the accumulation of fat inside hepatocytes and inflammatory cells, but no ballooning degeneration occurred in the liver; this finding is related to the fact that fructose inhibits hepatic fatty acid β-oxidation, which causes fat accumulation in the liver (
29).
Moreover, fructose increases the level of free fatty acids by stimulating the activity of enzymes in the de novo lipogenesis pathway, thereby increasing the synthesis and esterification of TG in the liver (
30). Transaminases are used mainly to assess biochemical changes in the liver; an increase in these enzymes is an indicator of inflammatory response to injury (
31). In this study, there was no increase in transaminases in the FC group. We hypothesized that treatment for more than six weeks may result in the greater inflammation of liver cells and elevation of transaminases. However, we found an increase in the GGT level of the FC1 group, which was in line with the histological finding of bile duct proliferation.
5.1. Conclusion
The present results showed that six weeks of a low-dose CCl4 combined with 20% fructose led to the development of steatosis in male Wistar rats. However, CCl4 alone, increased hepatic steatosis and caused dyslipidemia as the main criteria for NAFLD. Therefore, this model can be the most effective experimental method for drug testing and clarifying the pathophysiology of NAFLD.