1. Introduction
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Problem Identification
2.2. Literature Search
| Database | Date | Keywords | Article Retrieved |
|---|---|---|---|
| PubMed | 2022, Oct & Nov. | Inborn errors of metabolism AND need AND care | 50 |
| Web of Science (ISI) | 2022, Oct & Nov. | 176 | |
| Google Scholar (English) | 2022, Oct & Nov. | 52600 | |
| Google Scholar (Persian) | 2022, Oct & Nov. | 28 | |
| SID (Persian) | 2022, Oct & Nov. | 284 |
2.3. Data Evaluation and Quality Appraisal
3. Results
| No. | Title | Authors/Year | Study Design | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Long-term needs of adult patients with organic acidemia: Outcome and prognostic factors | Martin-Hernandez et al./2009/UK (21) | Quantitative/reviewing medical records of 15 patients with organic acidemia | The multidisciplinary approach to care; need for support for the transition from adolescence to adulthood; most of them were dependent on their parents; appropriate counseling for women of childbearing age about pregnancy, childbirth, and its potential risks; nutritional needs such as tube feeding, nocturnal feeding for maintaining energy, supplements, diet restriction; different systems assessment based on the signs and symptoms of patients such as neurological problems, renal failure, cardiomyopathy, osteoporosis, optic problems. |
| 2 | Perspectives on dietary adherence among women with inborn errors of metabolism | Kemper et al./2010/USA (22) | Qualitative/focus groups | Dietary needs; need to educate about medical diet and sources of medical foods, preparation of medical foods; need insurance coverage for medical foods; need to assist with the transition from pediatric to adult healthcare providers; need to develop symptom-based dietary monitoring |
| 3 | Inborn errors of metabolism: Psychosocial challenges and proposed family systems model of intervention | Weber et al./2012/USA (23) | Review | Need support as they focus on immediate practical demands, grieve over illness; related losses and reorient future expectations |
| 4 | Living with an inborn error of metabolism detected by newborn screening: Parents’ perspectives on child development and impact on family life | Gramer et al./2014/Germany (24) | Quantitative/descriptive | Need for comprehensive multidisciplinary care, including psychological, financial, and social support |
| 5 | A national survey of providers treating patients with metabolic disorders identified by newborn screening demonstrates challenges faced by clinical care systems | McClain et al./2015/USA (25) | Survey on 114 healthcare providers working with IEM patients and families | Lack of insurance coverage; lack of reimbursement for the services; system-level interventions are needed to support the development of and access to interventions and for coordination of healthcare delivery; need for more communication between healthcare professionals; to restructure the fragmented healthcare delivery system to favor patient-centered, coordinated care while slowing an unsustainable trend in rising healthcare costs |
| 6 | Experiences of caregivers of children with inherited metabolic diseases: A qualitative study | Siddig et al./2016/Canada (26) | Qualitative | Specialized diet needs; children's social needs; social support for parents; fitting in with peers; need for coordinated care across the healthcare team |
| 7 | Child and family experiences with inborn errors of metabolism: A qualitative interview study with representatives of patient groups | Khangura/2016/Canada (27) | Qualitative | Need for specific improvements in health services, such as better care coordination; need for achieving a diagnosis; need to receive appropriate support |
| 8 | Parent coping and the behavioral and social outcomes of children diagnosed with inherited metabolic disorders | Brown et al./2017/Australia (28) | Quantitative/cohort (multiple questionnaires accomplished by 22 parents) | Need for a multidisciplinary team for supporting families and considering biopsychosocial factors; parents need psychological assessment and support after the diagnosis of IEM |
| 9 | Difficulties in daily life and associated factors and quality of life of children with inherited metabolic disease and their parents in Japan: A literature review | Yamaguchi et al./2017/Japan (29) | Review | Need to expand education for primary care physicians about IEM patients; psychological support for families; social support for parents; assessment of children and families' health status, burden, and stress at regular clinic visits; support groups for associate families who have similar experiences to peer support; need for attentive hearing, empathy, and recipiency in daily clinical practice by medical professionals; patient education about diet therapy; education about self-care with consideration for the child's growth and development, intelligibility, and sense of values, and with praise for the child's efforts |
| 10 | Parenting a Child with Phenylketonuria (PKU): An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) of the Experience of Parents | Carpenter et al./2018/UK (30) | Qualitative: Interpretive phenomenology | Need for acceptance of diagnosis and management; educational need; support from others |
| 11 | What are the information needs of parents caring for a child with Glutaric aciduria type 1? | Piercy et al./2019/UK (31) | Qualitative focus group | The need to be active partners in medical management to feel in control of the situation through understanding the condition and managing the condition by ensuring the restricted regimen |
| 12 | The need for additional care in patients with classical galactosemia | Welling et al./2019/Netherland (9) | Quantitative/cross-sectional | Dietary needs; need for additional care in the domains of mental function, speech, and voice; need to monitor the appearance of the potential impairments associated with the disease |
| 13 | The impact of disease severity on the psychological well-being of youth affected by an inborn error of metabolism and their families: A one-year longitudinal study | Dimitrova et al./2021/Switzerland (32) | Quantitative/Longitudinal | A child psychologist specializing in IEMs; receiving highly specialized interdisciplinary care at a tertiary center |
| 14 | New recommendations for the care of patients with mucopolysaccharidosis type I | Bay et al./2021/Argentina (33) | Review | Need for early diagnosis and treatment and an interdisciplinary follow-up |
| 15 | Inborn Errors of Metabolism in Pediatric Palliative Care | Harputluoglu et al./2021/Turkey (34) | Quantitative/cross-sectional | Need for social, physical, psychological, and physiotherapy |
| 16 | Exploring the experiences of family caregivers with low income accessing healthcare services for children with inborn errors of metabolism | Chimney/2022/Canada (1) | Qualitative/Grounded Theory/Thesis | Unmet needs: Psychological support; financial resources; providing education; local community events; flexibility in care |
| 17 | “Why them, why me, why us?” The experiences of parents of children with lysosomal acid lipase deficiency: An interpretative phenomenological analysis study | Hassall et al./2022/UK (35) | Qualitative/Phenomenology | Need for psychological support of family |
| 18 | Unmet Needs of Parents of Children with Urea Cycle Disorders | Scharping et al./2022/Germany (36) | Quantitative/prospective single-center pilot study | Need for information on the growth and development of children; information on current or future services available for children; additional supporting services; support in finding a suitable caretaker; talk to other affected families; support for insomnia, fatigue, loss of appetite, finding meaning in the situation, physical exhaustion; support for the feeling of being useless, powerless, and helpless; additional support groups; psychological support |
| 19 | Unmet Needs of Children with Inherited Metabolic Disorders in the COVID-19 Pandemic | Ozalp Akin et al./2022/Turkey (37) | Quantitative/cross-sectional | Need for special services and rehabilitation; need for financial support; Domains of services: Healthcare needs: Access to healthcare for follow-up; receiving medicine; support for specific diet; Educational needs: Preschool education; schooling; Special services and rehabilitation: Special education for cognitive difficulties; physiotherapy; speech and language therapy; vision/hearing rehabilitation; occupational therapy. |
Abbreviation: IEM, inborn errors of metabolism
a Articles are sorted ascending by the date of publication.
| Children with IEM | Parents or Caregivers | Healthcare System |
|---|---|---|
| Dietary and nutritional needs (5): Tube feeding, nocturnal feeding, supplements, diet restriction; education about medical diet and sources of medical foods, preparation of medical foods; development of a symptom-based dietary monitoring; specialized diet Social needs (3): Fitting with peers; education about preschool and schooling Psychological support (4): A child psychologist specialized in IEMs; improvement of the quality of life; regular health status, burden, and stress check at regular clinic visits Different systems’ assessments and additional needs (4): Mental function; cognitive difficulties; speech and voice; vision and hearing; monitoring potential impairments; musculoskeletal and physical function; growth and developmental monitoring; physiotherapy; occupational therapy; special services and rehabilitation Self-care education with consideration for the child's growth and development, intelligibility, and sense of values, and with praise for the child's efforts (1) | Psychological support (9): Support as they focus on immediate practical demands, grieve over illness-related losses and reorient future expectations; psychological assessment and support after the diagnosis of IEMs; attentive hearing, empathy, and recipiency in daily clinical practice by medical professionals; support for achieving acceptance; social worker in the team; support for the feeling of being useless, powerless, and helpless; support for insomnia, fatigue, loss of appetite, finding meaning in the situation, physical exhaustion; regular health status, burden, and stress at regular clinic visits Social support (5): Associate families who have similar experiences to peer support; local community events; finding a suitable caretaker; additional support groups; involving others to care for the child as he/she is growing Educational need (2): Management of disease; information on the growth and development of children; information on current or future services available for children; additional supporting services Financial support (2) Managing the condition (4): Achieving a diagnosis; flexibility in care; being an active partner in medical management to feel in control of the situation | Multidisciplinary approach for care, including psychological, financial, and social support in which clinician and dietician be the core (5): Patient-centered and coordinated care between patients, families, and healthcare providers (3); support for the transition from adolescence to adulthood (2); appropriate counseling for women of childbearing age about pregnancy, childbirth, and its potential risks Healthcare systems-level interventions (3): Access to healthcare for interventions and follow up; receiving medicine; support for specific diet; insurance coverage of medical foods, and medical services; expanding education about IEMs for primary care physicians (1) |
Abbreviation: IEM, inborn errors of metabolism
