This study indicated a notable patient satisfaction level with a generally positive perception of the quality of nursing care provided in the ED. This result aligns with previous reports highlighting the positive impact of nursing care on patient satisfaction (
23). The research showed that using nursing theories, like Peplau's interpersonal relations theory, which includes four stages: Orientation, identification, exploitation, and resolution, ensures that patients feel understood and supported, leading to greater satisfaction with their nursing care (
24).
Studies have shown that effective nursing care, characterized by respect, attentiveness, and clear communication, significantly affects overall patient satisfaction. According to Ratna Sari et al. (
23), effective communication is significantly associated with excellent service quality and increased patient satisfaction with healthcare. In contrast, the present study found no significant relationship between nurse-patient communication and patient satisfaction.
Several factors can be attributed to the lack of a significant correlation between nurse-patient communication in the ED and patient satisfaction. A key factor is the chaotic and rapid dynamics of the ED setting, which frequently obstructs clear communication. The presence of noise and unpredictability poses significant challenges for nurses, hindering their ability to foster meaningful interactions with patients and ultimately impacting the quality of communication (
25).
Furthermore, the intricate nature of communication in the ED is intensified by the varied needs and expectations of patients. Patients exhibit diverse preferences when it comes to communication styles, and what meets the needs of one individual may not necessarily meet the needs of another. This variability may weaken the overall relationship between communication and satisfaction (
26). Also, although nurses may exhibit caring behaviors, they may not consistently result in perceived satisfaction if patients do not feel sufficiently informed or engaged in their care choices (
27).
Further consideration is the possible disparity between the communication abilities of nurses and the particular requirements of patients, which may result in unfulfilled expectations (
28). In this study, patient satisfaction was significantly related to educational level and sex, with greater satisfaction reported among female patients and patients with higher educational levels. This finding aligns with existing evidence suggesting that educated patients have higher expectations regarding their care and are more likely to articulate their needs and preferences (
29).
Approximately 95% of the patients in this study confirmed that nurses treated them with respect, indicating that nearly all patients felt respected by nursing staff. According to Karaca and Durna (
30), nurses generally adopt a communication style that is respectful and friendly toward patients. However, nurses tend to be less interested in providing explanations about their interventions and communicating with patients who do not meet their expectations. In the current study, the patients indicated receiving the best possible care from their nurses, highlighting their overall satisfaction.
Respectful nurse-patient communication reduces the likelihood of miscommunication, makes patients feel secure during nursing care, enhances patient participation in decision-making, improves adherence to medication and treatment plans, increases safety, and enhances patient satisfaction with care. Therefore, good nurse-patient clinical communication is essential for improving patient-centered care and achieving favorable healthcare outcomes. The results of this study are aligned with those from other studies conducted in a similar direction (
31).
Molina-Mula and Gallo-Estrada (
32) conducted in-depth interviews to examine the implications of the nurse-patient relationship for clinical practice, care quality, and patient decision-making ability. They found that positive nurse-patient interaction shortened hospital stays and enhanced care quality and satisfaction. Additionally, the patients’ submissive role was a prerequisite for a positive relationship. Based on the findings, the nurse-patient relationship should not aim to alter patients’ beliefs or practices; instead, nurses should act as observers of patients’ and their families’ experiences with the health and illness processes.
Yoo et al. (
33) conducted focus group discussions and in-depth interviews to evaluate the communication experiences of critical care nurses in an intensive care unit. They identified three key themes: Dealing with unforeseen communication challenges, acquiring skills through trial and error, and recognizing the importance of communication experiences in providing care. Nurses acknowledged that effective communication is essential for delivering high-quality treatment. The results, aligning with those of the present study, emphasized that nurses should continuously strive to develop new communication skills and improve their existing abilities when interacting with patients and their caregivers.
In the current study, the majority of the nurses reported that their communication with patients during care procedures was generally good. This finding is supported by previous reports suggesting that effective communication in the ED may not always be feasible due to the immediate demands of emergency treatment procedures and the need for external ventilation support (
34,
35). Furthermore, prior research indicates that nurses may often prioritize task-oriented care over engaging in conversations with patients, families, and caregivers (
36).
There are limitations to this study, including: The cross-sectional design of this study, along with the reliance on convenience sampling, may have led to potential bias, which could restrict the generalizability of the results. Furthermore, the study did not thoroughly examine the relationships between demographic variables (such as sex, age, marital status, and educational level) and nurse-patient communication, which may serve as confounding factors affecting patient satisfaction. Also, using only ANOVA without multivariate regression analysis made it harder to deal with these factors that could affect the results and fully understand how they affected the results.
5.1. Conclusions
Effective communication is essential for achieving positive patient satisfaction; however, this study did not find a direct relationship between nurse-patient communication and patient satisfaction, highlighting the multifaceted and complex nature of care. Demographic factors, such as educational level and gender, significantly influence patient satisfaction and should be considered in tailoring communication strategies. Healthcare organizations should prioritize enhancing nurses’ communication skills through targeted training, reducing workload, and fostering supportive work environments.
Future studies should address these gaps by exploring the interplay between demographic and confounding factors, employing advanced statistical techniques such as multivariate regression, conducting longitudinal research, and utilizing qualitative methods like interviews or focus groups to provide deeper insights into communication challenges and patient preferences.