This study combined a gelatin–alginate delivery matrix with HDF-CM and evaluated both material behavior and fibroblast responses relevant to skin repair. The HDF-CM-loaded hydrogel exhibited high water uptake and released protein over seven days, while the biological assays showed increased fibroblast metabolic activity and migration, as well as a shift in COL1A1, COL3A1, and MMP1 expression, compared with free HDF-CM or blank hydrogel. These observations support a carrier-associated difference in vitro; however, they should not be interpreted as evidence of complete skin regeneration.
The material findings are consistent with the broader hydrogel literature, in which hydrated polymer networks are used to maintain a moist environment and enable controlled local delivery of bioactive agents (
7-
11). The observed initial release followed by slower release is compatible with diffusion and network–cargo interactions in hydrated matrices. However, total protein release alone does not establish preservation of individual growth factors or extracellular-vesicle bioactivity; future studies should therefore quantify selected HDF-CM components before loading and after release.
Conditioned media contain heterogeneous paracrine factors that can influence fibroblast survival, proliferation, migration, and matrix regulation (
3-
6). The increased metabolic activity and scratch closure observed with HDF-CM exposure are therefore biologically plausible and align with prior reports of secretome-mediated fibroblast responses (
3,
4,
11,
12). The stronger response in the hydrogel-delivered group may reflect prolonged local presentation; however, the current design cannot distinguish release kinetics from concentration effects unless free and hydrogel-delivered HDF-CM are rigorously matched for protein dose and batch.
The increase in COL1A1 and COL3A1 together with lower MMP1 expression indicates a shift in extracellular-matrix-related transcription. This pattern may be relevant to matrix formation, but it is not equivalent to increased collagen protein deposition or improved tissue repair. Collagen accumulation and matrix degradation are temporally regulated during healing, and excessive or prolonged collagen synthesis can contribute to fibrosis (
1,
2,
13). Accordingly, future experiments should pair transcript measurements with collagen protein assays and broader remodeling markers.
The use of a cell-free HDF-CM formulation may offer practical advantages over direct administration of living cells, including simplified storage and delivery. Nevertheless, conditioned medium is intrinsically heterogeneous, and donor source, passage, serum exposure, conditioning time, storage, and batch processing can alter its composition (
5,
6,
9). Reproducible translation will require predefined manufacturing controls, potency assays, and reporting of batch-to-batch variability.
The scope of the present study is limited to in vitro fibroblast responses relevant to skin repair. The study did not directly assess keratinocyte re-epithelialization, endothelial angiogenesis, inflammatory responses, collagen deposition, or in vivo wound closure. Therefore, the findings should not be generalized to whole-skin regeneration or clinical efficacy. Future work should extend the system to keratinocyte, endothelial, and immune-cell models and, if supported by those results, to an appropriately designed in vivo wound model.
5.1. Conclusions
A gelatin–alginate hydrogel incorporating HDF-CM showed sustained protein release through day 7 and was associated with increased fibroblast metabolic activity and scratch closure, higher COL1A1/COL3A1 expression, and lower MMP1 expression in this in vitro model. These findings are restricted to fibroblast responses relevant to skin repair and do not demonstrate whole-skin regeneration or in vivo therapeutic efficacy. Verification in independent biological replicates, standardized HDF-CM batches, multicellular assays, and in vivo studies is required before translational conclusions can be drawn.
5.2. Limitations and Future Work
• The biological sample size was small; independent replication should be expanded to improve precision and the robustness of assumption checks.
• HDF-CM composition is heterogeneous and should be characterized using representative soluble factors and, where relevant, extracellular-vesicle-associated markers.
• Free HDF-CM and hydrogel-delivered HDF-CM should be compared at rigorously matched protein doses and across dose-response and time-course conditions.
• Fibroblast metabolic activity, migration, and mRNA expression do not establish whole-skin regeneration. Future studies should assess collagen protein deposition, keratinocyte re-epithelialization, endothelial angiogenesis, inflammatory-cell responses, and in vivo wound closure.
• Protein stability and biological potency after hydrogel encapsulation and release require direct measurement.