The long-term renal outcomes of acquired solitary kidney depend on the age at onset, lifestyle, dietary habits, residual nephron mass immediately post-nephrectomy, duration of solitary kidney, and associated comorbidities. Acquired solitary kidney (unilateral nephrectomy due to donation or post-trauma) is usually seen in young or middle-aged individuals, while malignancies are common causes of unilateral nephrectomy in older individuals with associated comorbidities, increasing the risk of CKD progression. Garg et al. (as cited by Matas and Rule) compared 1,278 living donors with 6,359 controls and found that hypertension was more frequent among living donors (16.3%) compared to controls (11.9%) after six years of follow-up (
34). Living kidney donors can develop proteinuria over time. A meta-analysis of 48 studies including 5,048 donors reported an average 24-hour proteinuria of 154 mg/day after an average of seven years post-donation, with an average GFR of 86 mL/min (
6). Kidney disease improving global outcomes (KDIGO) guidelines recommend assessing albuminuria in living kidney donors at least once a year (
6). Using administrative data, Lam et al. (as cited by Matas and Rule) compared 604 living kidney donors with 2,214 controls and observed an increase in eGFR of 0.35 mL/min/1.73 m
2 per year in living donors after seven years of median follow-up, while controls had a significantly decreased eGFR (-0.85 mL/min/1.73 m
2 per year) (
34). Recently, seven studies conducted in six different countries showed no difference in cardiovascular mortality between living donors and matched controls (
34). From October 16, 1987, to November 3, 2020, data from the US Scientific Registry of Transplant showed that 633 living donors (0.4%) developed ESRD (
34). According to Wainright et al. (as cited by Matas and Rule), the risk of developing ESRD in living donors was significantly higher among recipients’ first-degree relatives (maximum in identical twins) than among unrelated living donors (
34). There is evidence of living donors surviving for more than 50 years. However, longer follow-up studies among living donors, including the University of Minnesota series and Canadian series, reported a mean interval of 27 years from donation to the development of ESRD (
30). Keys et al. studied 66 living donors who donated 50 or more years earlier and reported that 22 (33.3%) were still alive (
35). Sanchez et al. (as cited by Matas and Rule) studied risk factors for CKD onset in living donors at the time of kidney donation and reported that smoking, higher BMI, older age, hyperlipidemia, and high systolic and diastolic BP were associated with the development of proteinuria and CKD later on in living donors (
34). African American individuals and the APOL1 genotype may be associated risk factors for the development of CKD among living donors in the long term, as in the general population (
34). Pregnancy causes anatomical and physiological changes in the kidney, such as an increase in size and GFR. Ibrahim et al. (as cited by Matas and Rule) reported that risks for the development of hypertension and preeclampsia were higher in pregnancies after donation compared to pregnancies before donation (
34). This increased risk of preeclampsia is equivalent to that observed in females with high BMI, gestational diabetes, and chronic hypertension (
34). Therefore, living donors of childbearing age must be aware and informed that pregnancies after donation are considered high risk.
An average 11-year follow-up study of 125,427 living kidney donors showed that glomerulonephritis was the leading cause of ESRD in the first ten years after kidney donation, whereas after ten years, diabetes mellitus and hypertension were common causes of ESRD among living kidney donors (
32,
36). The major cause of ESRD in living kidney donors appears to be environment-related renal diseases or immunological factors rather than hyperfiltration-induced FSGS and CKD progression (
6,
32).
Seun Kim et al. studied deceased donor recipients and living donor recipients, reporting a three-year better outcome in living donor recipients and lower proteinuria levels in deceased donor recipients where donor kidney weight was higher than recipient body weight (
37). Young et al. compared living kidney donors with non-donor controls and found that higher levels of serum intact fibroblast growth factor 23 (FGF-23), renal tubular fractional excretion of inorganic phosphorus, lower serum calcitriol, and lower serum phosphorus levels might indicate early onset CKD among living kidney donors (
38). Therefore, evidence suggests an overall increased risk of CKD progression among living kidney donors, although the absolute risk remains small. A solitary functioning kidney should not be considered harmless. The distinguishing features of congenital and acquired solitary kidneys are shown in
Table 1 (
7,
13,
39).