1. Context
2. Objectives
3. Data Sources
4. Study Selection
4.1. Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
5. Data Extraction
5.1. Data Collection
5.2. Evaluation of Article Quality
5.3. Data Analysis
6. Results
6.1. Educational Challenges
| Subcategory | Explanation | Number | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Course content | The current content of students' courses is not suitable for using AI as an educational tool. | 1 | (5) |
| Decreased critical thinking skills | The use of AI in education may reduce students’ critical thinking skills. | 4 | (16-19) |
| Comprehensiveness of AI algorithms | The comprehensiveness of AI algorithms may not be sensitive to the diversity of patient populations and different cultures. | 1 | (16) |
| Over-reliance on technology | Students may use the tools of AI will become overly dependent and lose various skills such as critical thinking, human communication, problem solving, and relationship building. | 3 | (20-22) |
| False self-confidence | Student use From AI It may increase students’ false self-confidence. | 1 | (23) |
| Limitation of human interaction | The use of AI for education may lead to a reduction in human interactions during the learning process. | 4 | (4, 23-25) |
| Educational justice | The use of AI tools may cause educational injustice and discrimination. | 2 | (22, 26) |
| Individual learning | AI may not take into account the individual capabilities of the student and the overall learning process may be considered. | 1 | (26) |
| Gap between training and practical needs | It is possible that due to changing treatment methods, AI cannot prepare graduates to enter the job market. | 1 | (27) |
| Inability to convey human emotions | AI cannot simulate emotions like empathy and compassion, which are at the core of the nursing profession. | 1 | (18) |
| Simplistic approaches | The AI may ignore the individual complexities of patients and provide answers based on simplistic approaches. | 1 | (18) |
Abbreviation: AI, artificial intelligence.
6.2. Technological Challenges
| Subcategory | Explanation | Number | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Inaccessibility | All universities and students have not the same access to technology. | 1 | (5) |
| Fragmentation of AI systems | The integration of AI systems with one another and with existing infrastructures is one of the most significant challenges in utilizing AI in nursing education. | 2 | (16, 17) |
| Algorithm bias | The AI models may possess biases stemming from their training data (age, race, etc.). This issue is particularly concerning for programs aimed at preparing nurses to work with diverse populations. | 4 | (20, 23, 26, 28) |
| Lack of complete understanding of algorithms | Some predictive algorithms and models in AI exist that experts cannot fully understand how they work or why they produce specific results. | 2 | (23, 29) |
| Possibility of error | Given the importance of nursing education and patient safety, it is essential that AI-developed scenarios are monitored and evaluated to identify and correct any errors or inaccuracies within them. | 1 | (25) |
| Organizations ' capacity to adopt technology | Lack of a clear strategy or clear leadership for accepting AI as an educational tool is also another challenge the use of this tool is for teaching nursing students. | 2 | (4, 30) |
Abbreviation: AI, artificial intelligence.
6.3. Ethical Challenges
| Subcategory | Explanation | Number | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Privacy rules | When using AI to educate nursing students, the privacy of students, patients, and instructors must be respected. | 8 | (4, 16, 17, 19, 23, 24, 27, 31) |
| Data security | The use of sensitive patient data in simulation and AI raises concerns about security. | 5 | (4, 16-18, 24, 29) |
| Plagiarism | With the increasing use of AI tools for text writing and content creation, there are concerns regarding plagiarism and the validity of student works. | 2 | (22, 23) |
| Responsibility | When using AI for education, is it unclear who is responsible for the content provided by this technology if an error occurs? | 2 | (18, 23) |
| Cheating and data fabrication | The use of AI may cause copying or data mining among students when presenting assignments. | 4 | (18, 19, 21, 31) |
| Quality of care | Concerns regarding patient privacy and automated data collection may impact the quality of care | 1 | (6) |
| Legal parameters | There are no specific legal frameworks for using AI for nursing education. | 2 | (6, 22) |
Abbreviation: AI, artificial intelligence.
6.4. Trust Challenges
| Subcategory | Explanation | Number | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Biased data | Some AI systems may use data that is relevant to a specific community. | 2 | (5, 6) |
| Trust of students and instructors | Students and educators may be skeptical about the use of AI-based technologies or feel that these technologies cannot replace human interaction. | 2 | (5, 6) |
| Cultural sensitivity and inclusiveness | Algorithms must be sensitive to diverse patient populations in order to provide equitable learning experiences. | 1 | (17) |
| Data quality | If the data is inaccurate, incomplete, or biased, it may produce misleading information that can negatively impact students' learning. | 6 | (6, 19, 21, 23, 24, 29) |
| Data integrity | Challenge in collecting and analyzing data for training AI models due to the diversity of data sources. | 1 | (6) |
| Accuracy of answers | The AI-based tools may generate incorrect or inappropriate information, which can negatively affect students' learning and their confidence. | 3 | (4, 19, 23) |
| Distortion of reality | Artificial intelligence may produce unrealistic information to fill its weaknesses, which can mislead users. | 1 | (23) |
| Insufficient transparency | Many machine learning models exhibit a lack of transparency, which may lead to a decrease in nurses' trust in AI systems. | 1 | (29) |
| Lack of ongoing research and evaluation | There is a need for more research to evaluate the effectiveness and importance of pastoral education, to identify gaps in its implementation. | 2 | (28, 31) |
| Creation a valid tool for measurement | There is still no valid and reliable tool for measuring. The accuracy of the information provided by AI has not been established for training in various fields. | 1 | (28) |
| Alignment with nursing processes | The AI-generated educational content needs to be aligned with nursing practice processes and aligned with patient goals. | 1 | (25) |
Abbreviation: AI, artificial intelligence.
6.5. Human Challenges
| Subcategory | Explanation | Number | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trainer training | Educators must learn the ability to effectively use AI-based tools, which requires additional time and resources. | 5 | (5, 23, 25, 27, 30) |
| Change educational methods | Educators will need to modify their curricula and teaching methods to effectively integrate AI — which may require additional time and effort. | 1 | (21) |
| Resistance to change | One of the main challenges is the slow adoption of new technologies by educators, who often prefer to rely on traditional teaching techniques. | 3 | (6, 27, 32) |
| Need for rapid adaptation of teachers | The urgent need for teachers to adapt to this new technology requires appropriate educational planning and the provision of policies and training for responsible use. | 1 | (19) |
| Need for training and specialized courses | Lack of formal education about what AI applications can do. This is a serious obstacle to using this technology in nursing education. | 3 | (4, 6, 30) |
| Interaction between educators and technology experts | Use of AI nursing education requires collaboration between nursing educators and AI experts it is. | 2 | (16, 17) |
Abbreviation: AI, artificial intelligence.
6.6. Economic Challenges
| Subcategory | Explanation | Number | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost and resource allocation | Implementation And using AI to train nurses may require significant financial investment. | 2 | (16, 17) |
| Technology adoption | The high cost of implementing technologies AI may hinder widespread adoption of academic social networks. | 1 | (6) |
| Integration costs | The AI integration training requires significant investment in the provision of advanced technologies, specialized software, and ongoing technical support. | 1 | (24) |
| Support costs | To effectively integrate new technologies such as VR and XR, infrastructure must be properly supported, which may be costly or require major changes. | 1 | (31) |
Abbreviations: AI, artificial intelligence; VR,virtual reality; XR, augmented reality.

