This systematic review study aims to identify the challenges associated with the use of AI in nursing education. The researchers believe in the benefits of employing this technology; however, recognizing the challenges related to the implementation of AI in nursing education can not only prevent unintended problems but also help avoid the waste of financial and human resources. Based on the findings of this study, the challenges of using AI in nursing education can be categorized into six main groups: Educational, technological, ethical, trust-building, human resources, and financial challenges.
Buchanan et al. emphasize the necessity of adapting the curriculum when utilizing AI (
5). Additionally, Alkhaqani and Abdulai and Hung stress that special attention should be given to enhancing students' critical thinking skills when AI is employed for education (
18,
19). Krumsvik also notes that the use of AI may not adequately address the specific educational needs of individual students (
26).
The most significant challenge of using AI in health sciences education is the excessive reliance on technology. This issue can lead to a reduction in knowledge and a superficial understanding among students. On the other hand, such dependency hinders the development of essential skills like critical thinking and problem-solving. Therefore, educators and instructors must design and implement structured programs to strengthen these skills throughout students' education while being aware of these challenges.
White et al., along with Ball Dunlap and Michalowsk, indicate that the use of AI may perpetuate existing biases in training data (such as age, gender, race, etc.) (
28,
29). This can negatively impact the evaluations and feedback provided to students. Moreover, O'Connor et al. discuss the lack of understanding regarding how algorithms operate, noting that some algorithms and predictive models are referred to as "black box AI", meaning that even experts may not fully comprehend how they function or the reasons behind specific outcomes (
23).
To address the technical challenges associated with the use of AI, a variety of measures must be implemented, including government investment in this field to ensure universal access to this technology. Furthermore, employing standardized and specialized AI platforms can significantly aid in overcoming these challenges. Additionally, studying the history of a platform and comparing it with other AI platforms can help mitigate some of these issues.
Tam et al. note in their study that the use of this technology may result in increased copying among students, as they might rely on these tools to complete their assignments (
21). Detecting this type of cheating is difficult, as the text produced by AI typically does not match existing sources. Additionally, regarding privacy, Kavanagh and Sharpnack raises concerns, stating that AI cannot guarantee the confidentiality and privacy of information (
27).
The best solution for addressing the ethical challenges arising from the use of AI in health sciences education is to conduct workshops and training sessions for students. In these workshops, ethical and legal considerations should be addressed, and the consequences of cheating and data fabrication should be clearly outlined for participants. Moreover, before the commencement of training, students should be required to sign agreements affirming their commitment to maintaining privacy and data security.
O'Connor et al. indicate in their study that the dissemination of incorrect information by AI-based tools can negatively impact the education and evaluation of students (
23). Similarly, Srinivasan et al. acknowledge that issues related to data quality and access to necessary information can affect the effectiveness of AI (
24). Furthermore, Seibert et al. argue that the provision of erroneous results can lead to incorrect decision-making in care processes (
4).
The primary reason for the lack of trust among educators and students in AI in education is the uncertainty regarding the quality, accuracy, and reliability of the information. Therefore, the results and information provided by this technology should be critically assessed based on scholarly sources and literature.
Abuzaid et al. note that most nurses feel that curricula should include foundational knowledge about AI (
30). The lack of formal training regarding the applications of AI can pose a significant barrier to the integration of this technology into nursing practice. Shepherd emphasizes the need for appropriate training for educators and nurses on the use of advanced language models to address any concerns or misconceptions about AI technology (
25). It seems that the most important solution to address the human resource challenges in using AI in nursing education is to educate and inform the educators.
De Gagne and Jung state that implementing AI-based education may require significant financial investment (
16,
17). Krumsvik also points out that the high costs of implementing AI technologies may hinder the widespread adoption of these tools for student education (
26). Nassef and Zeid predict that the integration and assimilation of AI-based educational technologies may demand considerable investment (
31). Currently, the most viable solution for addressing financial challenges is to utilize free and shared platforms between institutions instead of those that incur costs.
7.1. Conclusions
The use of AI in nursing education can offer significant benefits, including improved educational quality, increased access to resources, and enhanced learning processes. This technology can assist educators and students in making better decisions regarding patient care by analyzing data and providing more accurate information. However, to effectively harness these advantages, it is essential to identify and address the existing challenges in this field. This study revealed that the challenges associated with the use of AI in nursing education can be categorized into six main groups: Educational, technological, ethical, trust, human, and financial challenges. Each of these categories has subcomponents that can negatively impact the learning process and the quality of education. In particular, issues such as distrust in data quality, algorithmic bias, and barriers related to the design and implementation of educational programs are among the most significant challenges. Identifying and analyzing these challenges can facilitate the integration of AI in nursing education and help prevent unintended problems.
7.2. Recommendations
In order to address the identified challenges, it is recommended that educational institutions develop comprehensive and targeted training programs for both teachers and students in the field of AI. These programs should encompass both theoretical and practical training on AI applications, while also addressing ethical and technological concerns. The design of educational programs must include clearly defined content, covering various aspects of AI such as machine learning, natural language processing, and computer vision, as well as diverse pedagogical approaches, including interactive workshops, lectures, and group projects to enhance effective learning experiences.