Nanosuspensions have received considerable attention in the drug delivery field for solubility and dissolution rate enhancement of hydrophobic drugs (
23). Nanosuspensions can be fabricated by top-down and bottom-up approaches. Wet media milling and HPH are top-down approaches for preparing nanocrystals (
24). Nanomilling is a process in which particle size reduction is obtained by the impaction of the milling medium with the drug particles. The robustness and reproducibility of nanosuspension preparation are governed by different formulations and operating factors (
25).
In this work, the effect of different stabilizers was studied on the particle size and PDI of quercetin nanosuspensions. The initial screening revealed that F68 was the most appropriate one, followed by TPGS and F127 (
Table 1). There was no significant difference in the mean particle size of F3, F4, and F5 formulations stabilized by the stabilizers as mentioned above (P > 0.05). Comparing the chemical structure of stabilizers, it can be noted that Pluronics are tri-block co-polymers consisting of two hydrophilic poly (ethylene oxide) (PEO) terminals with central hydrophobic poly (propylene oxide) (PPO) block (
26). F127 and F68 have the same basic structure but differ in the length of PEO and PPO groups. The slightly improved performance of F68 compared to F127 could be ascribed to its lower molecular weight, leading to a less restricted adsorption process and a faster diffusion (
27). Additionally, TPGS is composed of only one hydrophilic polar head and a hydrophobic alkyl tail (
28) and results in larger particle sizes than formulations stabilized by the polymers.
The intensity of grinding energy affects the performance of the wet media milling, and proper selection of the bead size plays a major role in the breakage kinetics (
29). Smaller beads (0.3 - 0.4 mm) resulted in finer nanoparticles at the same milling time (
Table 1). The possible reason is that the number of contact points is increased exponentially with a reduction in the size of milling beads, resulting in better grinding efficiency and, therefore, smaller particles.
According to the theory, the concentration of stabilizers should be sufficient to cover the entire surface of drug particles to provide a barrier against aggregation (
30). The particle size and PDI of nanosuspensions at two drugs: Stabilizer ratios (4:1 and 2:1) were investigated (F6 vs. F7). Results indicated that by increasing the concentration of F68, the particle size slightly decreased (P > 0.05). The higher stabilizer concentration allows the adsorption of more stabilizer molecules onto the surface of drug particles leading to better steric hindrance between the nanoparticles and particle size reduction (
31).
Regarding the effect of different drug loading, an increase in the drug loading from 2.5% to 5% led to a slight decrease in particle size (P > 0.05). This result could be attributed to additional attrition between the particles by higher solid content (
32). Moreover, with increasing drug amounts, more particles are trapped in the active grinding region between the milling beads, leading to improved milling efficiency. The latter assumption is in line with the findings of Cerdeira et al. working on miconazole nanosuspensions (
33). However, as shown in
Table 1, a further increase in drug loading to 10%, yielded a negative impact on the mean particle size. This was probably due to the insufficient collision between the drug particles and milling beads by increasing the drug content above an optimum level.
The final studied process variable was milling time. The mean size and PDI of nanoparticles decreased steadily with an increase in milling time. As reported by Alshora et al., this result could be attributed to the increased probability of collision between drug particles and milling beads (
34). Besides, increasing milling time provides sufficient time for the adsorption of the stabilizers onto the drug particles (
35). However, the particle size of quercetin was enlarged by a further increase in milling time beyond an optimum level (90 min), possibly, due to increased collision and aggregation between the newly generated particles. A similar trend has been reported by Yuan and coworkers, who investigated the effect of milling time on the mean particle size of nitrofurazone nanosuspensions (
36).
Lyophilization is a common drying method applied to stabilize nanosuspensions and increase their shelf life (
37). Cryoprotectants are used during the solidification step to prevent the irreversible aggregation of nanoparticles. Adding sugars or sugar alcohols as cryoprotectants prevents nanocrystalline aggregation during the drying processes (
38). The mean particle sizes of the reconstituted powders with cryoprotective agents were smaller than that of the control powders (
Table 2). This is because cryoprotectants protect the nanosuspensions from freezing damage caused by ice formation (
39). A concentration-dependent cryoprotection and a slight decrease (P > 0.05) in particle size at higher concentrations of cryoprotectants were observed, which could be due to better protection effects.
FTIR analysis was performed to gain insight into possible molecular interactions between the drug and stabilizer. As depicted in
Figure 2A, the spectrum of quercetin presented absorption peaks of hydroxyl, carbonyl, and aromatic groups, which are consistent with the values reported in the literature (
40,
41). The nanocrystal spectra appeared as the summation of quercetin, F68, and fructose, indicating that no chemical interaction occurred between the drug and stabilizer. The peak broadening at 3300 - 3500 cm
-1 may be attributed to the hydrogen bonding between quercetin and fructose hydroxyl groups.
XRD analysis was carried out to elucidate the physical structure of the drug in the nanocrystals. Based on the diffractograms presented in
Figure 2B, quercetin powder revealed its crystalline nature as proved by well-defined predominant diffraction peaks in the 2θ range of 10° - 30° (
42). Changes in the crystallinity of quercetin were qualitatively assessed based on the sharpness of the main characteristic peaks. The pattern of the wet-milled nanocrystal demonstrated differences in the intensity of peaks compared to the pure quercetin, which probably represents a slight reduction in crystallinity or partial amorphization of quercetin by nanomilling. These observations can explain the higher solubility of nanocrystals as compared to the unprocessed powder (
43).
Dissolution velocities of the nanocrystals were distinctly superior compared to the quercetin coarse powders and physical mixtures (
Figures 3A and
3B). The rate of drug dissolution could be described by the Noyes-Whitney equation (Equation 2), according to which the dissolution velocity (dc/dt) is proportional to the surface area (A) available for dissolution (
44).
In the equation, D is the diffusion coefficient, Cs is the saturation solubility, Ct is the bulk concentration, and h is the thickness of the diffusion layer. Particle size reduction down to the nanometric level increases the effective surface area.
Lai et al. reported a slight increase in the dissolution rate of physical mixtures compared to the bulk diclofenac powder due to the solubilization effect of stabilizers (
45). Contrary to expectations, we found that adding an equivalent amount of F68 present in nanoformulations to the quercetin powder could not improve the quercetin dissolution rate, probably due to insufficient quantity.
To improve long-term storage, we freeze-dried nanosuspensions shortly after milling to prepare solid formulations. The size of nanocrystals varied less than 10% during the stability test, suggesting desirable storage stability of the lyophilized form (
Figure 4). There was a negligible change in the quercetin content of the nanocrystals after four months of storage.
5.1. Conclusions
In the present study, quercetin nanosuspensions with mean diameters of less than 300 nm and uniform size distributions were prepared using the wet media milling technique with a careful selection of formulation and process parameters. Stabilizer type, drug: Stabilizer ratio, drug content, bead size, and milling time were identified as key factors throughout the experiment. Nanosuspensions were subsequently solidified to ensure their long-term stability. Based on these findings, wet media milling is a promising strategy for improving the dissolution rate and thus enhancing the oral bioavailability of quercetin and other poorly water-soluble drugs.