The results of the present study indicated that the mean NWL of infants 3 to 5 days after birth was 129 ± 92 grams, and they had lost 4.04 ± 3.19% of their birth weight. This is relatively consistent with the findings of Merry and Montgomery, who reported that infants had lost 4% to 9.8% of their weight, on average (
19). In a study conducted by Marchini et al., infants had lost 3% to 6% of their birth weight during the first 4 days after birth (
4). According to a study by Martinez et al., the mean WL within 3 to 5 days after birth was reported as 5.09 ± 2.89 (
2). The findings of the present study are consistent with the results of most previous studies in which the mean NWL was reported as 3% to 7% (
8-
10).
According to the results of the present study, breastfeeding increases WL ≥ 5% and WL ≥ 7% by 7 and 3 times, respectively, and this variable was the strongest predictor of NWL, as the mean WL in infants, who were exclusively breastfed (4.89 ± 2.86%), was higher than those fed with infant formula (2.78 ± 1.65%). McDonald also reported the same results in this regard (6.6% versus 3.5%) (
13). The results of the present study are consistent with the findings of most previous studies (
13,
15,
20); however, Davanzo et al. reported that the mean WL in infants, who were breastfed was lower than those fed with infant formula (6.3% versus 7.5%) (
16). This is inconsistent with the results of the present study and the concept that is widely accepted by the experience and knowledge of health care staff. This inconsistency could be due to different breastfeeding practices and protocols. According to the guidelines of the American academy of pediatrics (AAP), a WL of more than 7% within 3 to 5 days after birth is an indicator of possible breastfeeding problems (
21). Despite the proven benefits of breastfeeding, dehydration and poor weight gain after birth are common among infants, who are breastfed. These conditions are often preventable and if diagnosed early, they will not have long-term effects on infants (
14,
22,
23).
Since WL in infants, who are breastfed depends on the volume of milk they receive (
1,
24), breastfeeding protocols and practices must be taken seriously by infant-friendly hospitals, and these hospitals should train mothers, and establish other policies of successful breastfeeding. If these measures are taken before childbirth, they could reduce NWL in infants. Another reason for NWL in infants fed with formula in the present study was the late start of feeding with formula after a period of deprivation of breast milk (
16).
In the present study, cesarean section was another factor associated with NWL. This is consistent with the findings of Kagler (
14) and Davanzo (
16), who reported a direct relationship between cesarean section and weight loss after birth. It has been proven that, regardless of the type of infant feeding, NWL depends on the type of delivery. Researchers believe that feeding less than optimal levels after C-section may lead to greater levels of NWL. In fact, despite the promotion of “natural” CS and special training programs about breastfeeding, CS oppositely affects the initiation and duration of breastfeeding, especially after emergency cesarean section, and lower values of breastfeeding may be due to a lack of mother’s recovery after surgery (
25).
According to the results of this study, gender is one of the risk factors for NWL. In a study conducted by Jane (2010), female gender was one of the predictors of NWL in the first 24 hours after birth (
26). However, female gender in the present study was associated with the type of breastfeeding, as the female to male ration in infants, who were breastfed, was 118 to 100, while this ratio in infants fed with formula was 52 to 100. Therefore, WL in female infants is influenced by their breastfeeding type. As a result, health care providers should be sensitive to WL in female infants, who are breastfed, especially if they are born through cesarean section.
Although no significant relationship was found between WL and parity in the present study, WL in infants of mothers, who had no experience of breast feeding was reported to be 5% to 7%. In other studies, the effect of the number of pregnancies as a predictor of NWL has been mentioned as a contradictory result. Some studies have reported a positive relationship between WL and nulliparity (
15), while Patricia et al. observed no relationship between the number of pregnancies and NWL (
2). In the present study, in addition to the number of pregnancies, mother’s breastfeeding experience was also evaluated. The results indicated that mother’s ability to breastfeed her infant seems to be more effective than the number of pregnancies in NWL during the first days after birth, and mothers, who do not manage to successfully breastfeed their infants in their first pregnancy, will be at risk in their next pregnancy.
In this study, infants weighing more than 4000 grams lost more weight than others. In a study by Wright et al., weight was a strong predictor of WL. In their opinion, large-for-gestational age and breastfed infants lose more weight (
5). These differences are probably due to variables such as mother and infant’s characteristics, breastfeeding management, nutritional protocols in hospitals, and attitudes and skills of health care workers (
16). It has been widely accepted that breastfeeding is the best way of feeding infants, and pediatricians greatly emphasize the expansion of breast milk use. Health professionals, who are involved with these issues, have reached a consensus on the success of breastfeeding. In addition, it is very important to identify potential problems and barriers to successful breastfeeding, and denial of such problems leads to growth impairment. Since providing support and advice to nursing mothers may be insufficient, regular and indirect monitoring of weight will be helpful in evaluating feeding as either adequate, requiring infant formula supplement, or expressed breast milk. American Academy of Pediatrics (2012) recommended the policy of “Breastfeeding and the Use of Human Milk” for infants, who are breastfed and lose more than 7% of their weight (
27). Prevention or at least early diagnosis of hypernatremia, as one of the most serious complications of EWL, should be a top priority for any health care system (
28).
The results of the present study are corroborated by the findings of previous studies and add breastfeeding experience to other risk factors of NWL.
5.1. Study Limitations
In the present study, infants, who had been hospitalized for more than 3 days and probably lost more weight, were not included in the study because of not visiting the health centers on the third to fifth day of birth, thus the mean values of NWL obtained in the present study may be underestimated. To fix this limitation, we considered intensive care after birth as one of the exclusion criteria.
5.2. Conclusion
The study findings revealed that breastfeeding and cesarean section are the strongest predictors of NWL. Therefore, it is necessary for infant-friendly hospitals to come up with strategies to reduce the rate of cesarean section and establish successful breastfeeding before mothers are discharged.