PCOS is a multifactorial endocrine, reproductive, and metabolic disorder that affects women in their reproductive years (
27). Among the various experimental animal models established for the induction of PCOS, the DHEA model implemented in our study has been shown to generate both PCOS traits and IR (
28). We confirmed that DHEA exposure of post-pubertal Sprague Dawley rats resulted in an increase in body weight, number of cystically dilated follicles, serum LH, fasting serum insulin, and HOMA-IR, as compared to age- and weight-matched controls. Compared to the control group, PCOS rats had a significantly lower ovarian protein expression of PPARγ, IRS1, and Akt. Conversely, the PCOS group showed an increased mTOR pathway activity as evident by an increased protein expression of phosphorylated mTOR as compared to controls. When treated with oral MOE, the DHEA-induced PCOS rats showed a statistically significant decrease in body weight, LH serum levels, and the number of cystically dilated follicles compared to the non-treated PCOS rats, but not to control rats. In the MOE-treated rats, the protein expression of PPARγ, IRS1, and Akt was increased, while the mTOR activity was decreased compared to the non-treated PCOS group. Thus, MOE activates PPARγ in the ovaries and ameliorates the DHEA-induced PCOS phenotype. The effects of MOE may be, in part, due to the activation of the PI3K pathway and/or inhibition of the mTOR pathway.
In the current study, there was a significant increase in the rats’ body weight gain compared to controls around the third week after starting DHEA injections. Kim et al. noted a similar pattern of body weight increase with DHEA injections of Sprague Dawley rats that also developed PCOS (
29). Moreover, PCOS and obesity have long been linked in many human studies. In a recent meta-analysis, obesity was found to be more prevalent in women with PCOS than in non-PCOS age-matched women (
30). However, in 2013, it was suggested that the higher rate of obesity in PCOS women compared to control may be a bias of increased self-referral of overweight women (
31). Indeed, PCOS is seen in both lean and obese females (
30). Furthermore, the global differences in body mass index (BMI) of various populations do not relate to the prevalence of PCOS in these populations; hence, a causal role of obesity in PCOS is unlikely (
32). The exact link between obesity and PCOS remains unclear. Our experimental model mimics many of the symptoms of PCOS. The weight gain we detected in the DHEA-injected rats may be part of the PCOS phenotype or an effect of the androgen injection (
4). MOE treatment of the DHEA/PCOS rats in our work resulted in a decrease in average body weight compared to the non-treated PCOS rats and even to control rats. Regardless of the mechanism of weight loss seen, this finding may suggest an anti-obesity utility for MOE.
We have confirmed that DHEA injections resulted in an increased serum LH level and in the number of cystically dilated follicles on ovarian histology. The histological findings were consistent with those used in the literature to diagnose PCOS (
33). The elevated LH, on the other hand, has been linked to premature luteinization of the granulosa cells, hypertrophy, and post-ovulatory follicular changes, and follicular arrest (
3). Therefore, the follicular arrest seen in the PCOS groups might be due to excess serum LH. In PCOS, a disrupted hypothalamic GnRH secretion may lead to elevated serum LH, resulting in hyperandrogenic theca cells, follicular arrest, and increased number of pre-antral follicles (
34,
35). In this study, the serum LH levels normalized when the PCOS rats were treated with MOE. This may possibly explain the reversal of the phenotype with a significantly reduced number of cystic follicles in the ovaries compared to non-treated PCOS rats.
We have noted that injection of rats with DHEA resulted in metabolic derangement, namely the development of IR as measured by HOMA-IR. PCOS is known to be associated with an increased risk of metabolic abnormalities, including IR and type II diabetes (
5). IR is suspected to play a major role in the pathogenesis of PCOS, although the exact pathophysiologic association between IR and PCOS remains undetermined (
6). The DHEA-injected rats in our study had normal fasting glucose but developed hyperinsulinemia as compared to controls. Hyperinsulinemia further aggravates the hyperandrogenic phenotype in PCOS by inhibiting the hepatic synthesis of SHBG (
9), thus increasing the availability of free testosterone in circulation (
10).
Insulinomimetic peptides such as IGF1 are integral to the normal female body growth, patterning, and metabolism during puberty (
36). IGF1 regulates oocyte and follicular development, with strong evidence suggesting its possible involvement in the pathogenesis of metabolic syndrome and PCOS (
37). IGF1 and its binding protein IGFBP1 are secreted by the ovary and the liver. The highest rates of IGF-1 production occur during the pubertal growth spurt. IGF1 levels are increased in PCOS women, while IGFBP1 levels decrease, leading to an arrest in the development and the growth of the follicles (
38). Even among healthy females, a state of transient IR, associated with the increased activity of the IGF1, occurs mid-puberty followed generally by a return of insulin sensitivity (
39). It may be during this time that PCOS develops in genetically susceptible females.
There is an apparent overlap between the pathogenesis of IR and PCOS. In recent years, insulin sensitizing agents have been successfully utilized in managing symptoms of PCOS (
12,
40). TZD treatment has demonstrated increased induction of ovulation and increased rate of pregnancy in PCOS patients (
41). TZDs act via activating the PPARγ. PPARγ regulates ovarian functions and is downregulated by increased LH levels (
14) as those seen in PCOS. In this study, the DHEA/PCOS rats treated with MOE showed an increase in the ovarian expression of PPARγ compared to the PCOS group. Therefore, it is possible that direct ovarian PPARγ activation may be, in part, responsible for the improvement in PCOS symptoms seen with MOE, as is the case with TZDs.
MOE treatment of the DHEA/PCOS rats in our work showed an inhibition of the mTOR pathway in the ovary. This was evident by a decrease in the expression of the phosphorylated form of mTOR. Magnolol has been previously shown to inhibit mTOR in vitro (
20,
42). Additionally, studies have shown that in PCOS, mTORC1 is hyperactivated, while the insulin signal via the PI3 kinase/Akt pathway is attenuated (
43-
45). It has been postulated that the mTORC1 hyperactivation, triggered by elevated LH or androgens, generates a negative feedback loop on the insulin signaling pathway resulting in IR (
43-
45). We observed the same findings in our DHEA/PCOS rats, where p-mTOR was increased, while Akt and IRS1 expression was decreased, potentially contributing to the IR. However, upon our treatment of the DHEA/PCOS rats with MOE, the Akt and IRS-1 expression increased, supporting a potential insulin sensitizing effect of the extract on the ovaries.
TZDs and metformin improve insulin sensitivity by activating, directly or indirectly, the cellular energy sensor AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) (
46). PPARγ agonists are known activators of the AMPK pathway (
47). AMPK has a plethora of metabolic and proliferative effects, including negatively regulating mTORC1 (
46,
48). Thus, PPARγ agonist may, at least in part, improve insulin sensitivity through an AMPK-dependent signal. As a PPARγ agonist, MOE may exert an inhibitory effect on the mTOR pathway via activation of the AMPK pathway. In doing so, MOE removes the negative feedback loop on the insulin signaling pathway and restores insulin sensitivity.
Insulin-induced mTORC1 activity increases the expression of sterol regulatory element binding protein-1 (SREBP-1), a conserved lipogenic transcription factor that regulates cholesterol synthesis and ovarian steroidogenesis (
49). Interestingly, both SREBP-1 and mTOR activity are upregulated in animal models of type II diabetes (
50), and the expression level of SREBP1 is increased in the ovary of PCOS mice (
51) and in the serum of women with PCOS (
52). Therefore, it is possible that elevated SREBP1 activity may contribute to abnormal ovarian hormone production characteristics of PCOS.
4.1. Conclusions
In this study, the treatment of DHEA-induced PCOS insulin resistant rats with MOE normalized the polycystic ovarian morphology, LH levels, and molecular parameters. This effect may possibly be attributed to the PPARγ agonist properties of MOE and its ability to inhibit mTOR and activate the PI3k pathway, restoring insulin sensitivity. This study increased our understanding of the pathophysiological link between IR and PCOS. Finally, our results advocate the potential role of natural PPARγ agonists in the treatment of PCOS, where synthetic agonists have shown benefit yet, at the same time, serious and potentially fatal side effects.