In this study, suitable amounts of surfactant, cosurfactant, and oil were used after determining the concentration of dissolved KT to evaluate ME formulations. With respect to KT solubility in oil, surfactant, and cosurfactant, the best combinations for ketorolac ME preparations included isopropyl myristate (oil phase), Tween 80-Labrasol (surfactant mixture), and Pleurol oleic-PEG400 (cosurfactant mixture). Based on the phase diagrams, the width of the ME region increased with the S/C ratio (
15).
In our study, the average viscosity, pH, and droplet size of ME formulations were 38 - 135 cps, 5.1 - 5.7, and 28.36 - 61.06 nm, respectively. Based on the results of ANOVA test, pH had a significant association with the independent variable (%oil) (P < 0.05); in fact, pH increased at lower percentages of the oil phase in some ME formulations.
Based on the ANOVA test, a significant correlation was found between viscosity and independent variables (%oil, %water, and S/C ratio) (P < 0.05). Viscosity improved as the percentage of water, oil, and S/C ratio of ketorolac MEs decreased; this finding is in agreement with a study by Moghimipour et al. (
16).
In addition, the results of ANOVA showed an insignificant correlation between the independent variables and the mean droplet size (P > 0.05). Reduction in the particle size was associated with a great increment in the surface area, thereby improving skin permeability and bioavailability (
17). PI generally describes the droplet size uniformity. The index value was below 0.5 in our study, and therefore, the droplet size had a narrow distribution in ME formulations; this finding is in line with reports from the literature (
10). In addition, ME samples had a pH range of 5.1 - 5.7, which is appropriate for topical products.
According to the drug release profile, 88.04% of the drug was released within 24 hours (R24h) for ME-K-1, which consisted of 20% water, 22.5% surfactant, 50% oil phase, and 7.5% cosurfactant. As indicated by ANOVA, the independent variables (S/C ratio and %oil) had a significant correlation with the amount of released drug in two hours (R2h) (P < 0.05). In ketorolac ME formulations, R2h increased at lower oil phase percentages and S/C ratios.
Furthermore, the amount of released drug in 24 hours (R24h) was significantly associated with the independent variables (%oil and %water) (P < 0.05); in fact, any increase in the oil and water percentage phases increased R24h in the ME formulations. Our results show that ketorolac ME formulations with low levels of oil phase (5%) have a zero-order release mechanism.
Based on the cooling curves, free and bound water was collected at 0°C and -11°C - 25°C, respectively. According to ANOVA, independent variables were significantly associated with the bound melting transition temperature (T
m2) (P < 0.05); an increase in the oil percentage phase was associated with a significant increase in T
m2. In addition, the exothermic peak enthalpy of bound water was affected by the independent variables (P < 0.05). Owing to an increase in the oil percentage and S/C ratio, enthalpy was improved. In this regard, Podlogar et al. (
18-
20), reported similar behaviors; free water and bound water were respectively collected at -8°C to 0°C and -17°C to -26°C.
Based on the stability studies, a narrow PI was found in ketorolac ME formulations. This parameter indicates the ME vehicle stability. The vehicles were isotropic with transparent dispersions; no phase separation was observed after centrifugation. According to previous research on the stability of MEs, a complex relationship was found between thermodynamic stability and zero interfacial tension (
21).
In permeability experiments, the Jss parameter and independent variables (%water, %oil, and S/C ratio) were significantly associated (P < 0.05). An increase in water and oil phase percentage and reduction in S/C ratio caused an increase in Jss parameter in ketorolac ME formulations. The association between the independent variables and permeability coefficient (P) and apparent diffusivity coefficient (Dapp) was insignificant (P > 0.05).
Tlag was also significantly associated with the independent variables (%water and S/C ratio); in other words, an increase in Tlag was related to a reduction in the water phase percentage or an increase in the S/C ratio of ketorolac ME formulations. On the other hand, the independent variables had an insignificant correlation with the permeability coefficient (P) (P > 0.05).
The Jss and Papp parameters in ME-K-8 formulation, containing 20% water, 20% surfactant, 50% oil phase, and 10% cosurfactant were 0.114 mg/cm2.h and 0.057 cm/h, respectively (8.42 and 8.41 times higher than the control, respectively). The ME-K-8 formulation was found to be more suitable for transdermal ketorolac delivery, although further research is necessary.
The higher ketorolac permeability from ME formulations is probably attributed to the amount of cosurfactant, enhancing penetration (
22). Therefore, comparison of J
ss parameter in ME-K-1 (0.013 mg/cm
2.h) and ME-K-8 (0.114 mg/cm
2.h), with equal oil and water percentages and different surfactant and cosurfactant contents, may be related to the reduction in the cosurfactant content. Therefore, the amount of cosurfactant affects skin permeability in the formulations.
According to previous studies, the S/C content in ME vehicles majorly influences the skin permeation of hydroquinone (
23). Glycols (PEG400) can improve skin permeation through different mechanisms, including lipid and protein extraction, swelling of the stratum corneum, enhancing drug partitioning into the skin, and improving drug solubility in the formulation (
22). Tween 80 could accelerate hydrocortisone permeation (
24).
The permeability coefficient and flux from the rat skin increased significantly in all ME formulations with different features and compositions. In addition, several studies have confirmed the advantages of ME vehicles as promoters of dermal delivery (
23,
25), which can increase skin permeation by changing drug diffusion or partitioning coefficient (
22).
The effectiveness of ME formulations in the topical delivery of drugs has been attributed to different mechanisms. Considering the high solubilizing capacity of MEs, drugs can be used at large amounts in ME formulations. Also, the steady-state flux of the drug may be increased from ME formulation, as drug affinity to the internal ME phase may be changed effortlessly to support partitioning into the stratum corneum through a different internal phase (
15,
26-
28). Based on the findings, ketorolac ME formulations can promote permeation to improve transdermal drug delivery.
5.1. Conclusions
The present findings revealed that the amount of water, oil, and S/C components in the ME formulation majorly affects the physicochemical properties and permeability parameters. The kinetics of drug release from all the selected MEs were roughly described by the Higuchi model and showed a prolonged release compared to the ketorolac solution. The stability of ketorolac improved using the ME system. The studied MEs increased the skin permeation rate and permeability coefficient in rats.