Comparing the Effects of Topical Application of Honey and Nitrofurazone Ointment on the Treatment of Second-degree Burns with Limited Area: a randomized clinical trial

Tooran  Bagheri; Mohammad Javad  Fatemi; Seyed Abouzar  Hosseini; Mohsen  Saberi; Mitra  Niazi; Mahnoush  Momeni; Zahra  Masoumi

Medical-Surgical Nursing Journal

Current Issue All Issues In Press Articles Accepted Manuscripts Search

Boards and committees Indexing and Listing Sources Journal Metrics Open Peer Review (OPR)Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement Contact Us Support Journal Information Reviewer and AE Registration Form

APC

Authors Guide Submit Manuscript

Comparing the Effects of Topical Application of Honey and Nitrofurazone Ointment on the Treatment of Second-degree Burns with Limited Area: a randomized clinical trial

Author(s):

Tooran Bagheri¹,

Mohammad Javad Fatemi^2,*,

Seyed Abouzar Hosseini¹,

Mohsen Saberi¹,

Mitra Niazi¹,

Mahnoush Momeni¹,

Zahra Masoumi¹

1Iran

Medical-Surgical Nursing Journal:Vol. 5, issue 4; e67931

Published online:Jul 31, 2017

Article type:Research Article

Received:Feb 25, 2018

Accepted:Jun 10, 2017

How to Cite:Tooran BagheriMohammad Javad FatemiSeyed Abouzar HosseiniMohsen SaberiMitra NiaziMahnoush MomeniZahra Masoumiet al.Comparing the Effects of Topical Application of Honey and Nitrofurazone Ointment on the Treatment of Second-degree Burns with Limited Area: a randomized clinical trial.Med Surg Nurs J.5(4):e67931.

Abstract

Background: Burn is among the problems, which leads to numerous health and financial side effects for the patients and their families. The high costs of new dressings and burn rehabilitation have resulted in the increased tendency of researchers toward using complementary therapies and cost-effective ingredients such as honey with natural origin. Regarding this, the aim of this study was to compare the effect of topical use of honey and Nitrofurazone ointment on superficial second-degree burn healing.

Methods: This clinical trial was conducted on 50 patients with superficial second-degree burns referring to Yaftabad Hospital, Tehran, Iran, during 2013-2015. The participants were selected using the convenience sampling method, and then randomly assigned into two groups. The wounds were dressed daily until complete wound healing, with organic honey in one group and Nitrofurazone ointment and sterile gauze in the other group. For the purpose of the study, the two groups were compared in terms of such factors as pain intensity (for the first week), antibacterial activity (for the first week), histopathological parameters (14 days later), wound healing, and wound scar (6-12 months later). The comparisons were made through the visual analogue scale, laboratory culture results, pathologist’s ratings, daily photographs, and Vancouver Scar Scale, respectively. The data were analyzed using the SPSS software version 21 by the t-test and Chi-square test.

Results: According to the results, the patients’ pain intensity gradually decreased in both groups of honey (P<0.001) and Nitrofurazone (P<0.001) treatments and the pain intensity results showed better improvement in the honey group. Nevertheless, there was no significant difference between the two groups in this regard (P>0.05). Furthermore, the two groups showed no significant differences in terms of the epithelialization rate (P=0.52), inflammatory cells (P=0.71), vascularization (P=0.79), repair duration (P=0.43), and scar score (P=0.28).

Conclusion: As the findings of the present study indicated, honey and Nitrofurazoneon had comparable effects on the healing of second-degree burns (i.e., partial thickness) with less extended area. However, further studies are needed for the replacement of Nitrofurazone with honey.

Keywords

Honey

Nitrofurazone

Second-degree burn

Fulltext

-

References

comments