The objective of this work was to assess the effect of two exhausting race events on lipid peroxidation, antioxidant system, and muscle damage biomarkers in athletes (i.e. long-distance and middle-distance runners) and sedentary subjects.
Results relating to baseline MDA concentrations have not shown any significant difference between groups. This agrees with the findings of some researchers noting that chronic exercise has no effect on oxidative stress level at rest (
21). However, our data disagrees with the work of Marzatico et al. (
20) who noted initial MDA concentrations higher among marathoners and sprinters than sedentary subjects. Our data differed also from those of Zanella et al. (
27) who found initial levels significantly lower in professional footballers vs. sedentary subjects. According to Fisher-Wellman and Bloomer (
1), an optimal level of RONS production appears conducive to optimal health, whereas too little or too much RONS results in impaired defense capabilities or extensive oxidative damage and inflammation, respectively.
Our findings revealed also that lipid peroxidation increased from rest in SS and MDR at the end of the VAMEVAL test and in LDR after the Limited-Time test. In runners, the recorded values are greater when the exercise testing differs from the athlete’s sportive specialty. Several studies have likewise reported increased MDA blood release after a single bouts of exercise in sedentary males (
3), immediately after an exhaustive cycling exercise (
15), and immediately post-endurance exercise in marathoners (
20). In opposition to these findings, Niess et al. (
28) did not report increased MDA concentrations following a treadmill test to exhaustion, neither at 15 minutes nor at 24 hours post-exercise in trained and untrained individuals.
The training state affects also the level of lipid peroxidation induced by strenuous physical exercise namely when the physical exercise is most close to the athlete’s sportive specialty (
29). In fact, our results showed that, at the end of the incremental test, the lowest values were observed in LDR, and no difference observed in MDR vs. SS. However, after the incremental test, the lowest values were noted in MDR, and no difference noted in LDR vs. SS. These findings support many studies demonstrating a significant correlation between the training status, dietary intake, the intensity and volume of training and physical exercise damages (
1). The responsible mechanisms are still poorly understood, and remain a topic of debate. Nevertheless, according to Fisher-Wellman and Bloomer (
1), in addition to the increased resistance of tissues against the RONS damage (
29), health benefits from regular exercise come from a reduction of basal formation of oxidants and an improvement of antioxidant defense system. CAT with superoxide dismutase and glutathione peroxidase constitute the first endogenous enzymatic defense system against oxidative stress. CAT neutralizes large amounts of H
2O
2 from mitochondria, and the measurement of its activity constitutes a good indicator of the oxidative stress level (
1). Several studies have attempted to delineate the effect of chronic exercise on CAT activity. Nevertheless, the disagreement among the studies does not permit a clear picture to emerge. In fact, according to Lekhi et al. (
16), trained subjects have a lower resting plasma catalase activity than untrained subjects. They also reported decreased serum CAT activity in trained elite cyclists immediately after a progressive test on treadmill performed to determine VO
2max. on the contrary, Zembron-Lacny et al. (
19) and Kyparos et al. (
15) noted increased catalase activity in physical-education students exposed to a muscle-damaging resistance exercise and in well-trained rowers after a 2000-m rowing respectively.
Our results revealed also that the TAS decreased from rest in LDR and MDR respectively after the limited-time and the VAMEVAL test. No significant difference was found in SS and between groups or tests. This disagrees with the study of Diaz-Castro et al. (
30) which reported increased TAS in athletes after 50 km run. Our findings have discord also with those of Schneider et al. (
31) which revealed increased TAS levels in athletes at the end of 30 min of run on a treadmill at 10% below the anaerobic threshold. However, this work agrees with several studies reporting a significant decrease immediately post exercise (
17). Palazzetti et al. (
32) reported also decreased TAS concentrations at the end of an exhausting exercise in athletes after an overloaded training in triathlon. This decrease may reflect antioxidant compound transformations, through a process of RONS regeneration or neutralization produced during repeated metabolic phases stress.
Consistent with the latter assumption, we found that strenuous physical exercise induces muscle damage manifested by increased CK, LDH and myoglobin concentrations, and non-specific inflammatory response manifested by elevated concentrations of TNF-α and IL-6. Nevertheless, according to Pedersen et al. (
33), although the acute-phase response is initiated, exercise is not followed by a fully developed systemic response. This may be because the cytokine release in response to exercise is only transient or there may be an adaptation to the cytokine response.
Compared to other studies, our findings should be viewed within the context that the performed running tests were largely comprised of concentric muscle contractions which may attenuate RONS generation from muscle injury induced by eccentric contractions. Another limit of this study exists also in the fact that lipid peroxidation, antioxidant activity and muscle damage biomarkers were assessed only immediately after effort. Some biomarkers assessed in blood may take up to two hours after the cessation of exercise to be manifested. Therefore, an experimental design incorporating all studied variables at several time points during the recovery period will be very interesting. Nevertheless, it is important to practitioners, when scheduling a training program, to take into consideration: (i) the intensity and the volume of the last training session; (ii) the training state of subjects; and (iii) the similarity between exercises and the sportive specialty of athletes. In addition, a routinely assessment of redox status and muscle damages (1-fold / year or more) should be done mainly during the competitive period or at the end of the sportive season.
In conclusion, our findings indicate that maximal and supra-maximal race events, when sustained until exhaustion, induce significant modifications in blood redox balance reflecting the production of a significant oxidative stress in trained and untrained subjects. It is also noted that the training state and the sportive specialty produced different effects on the level of the oxidative stress. MDA concentration, TAS, and CAT activity were lower in LDR and MDR at the end of the VAMEVAL and the Limited-Time test, respectively. Strenuous physical exercise also induces muscle damage manifested by increased CK, LDH and myoglobin concentrations, and a non-specific inflammatory response manifested by elevated concentrations of circulating TNF-α and IL-6. Furthermore, the athletes showed a lesser magnitude of change in the cytokine levels following exhausting exercise than non-athletes. Neither the type of the test performed nor the sportive specialty affected the recorded values.