The purpose of this study was to report the yearly training load and injury incidence in highly trained youth table tennis athletes and assess if any relationship existed with injury occurrence. Previous studies have investigated the injury incidence in table tennis athletes (youth and senior) without reporting the training load over the course of a competitive season. In addition, to the authors’ knowledge, this represents the first report of typical training loads experienced by adolescent table tennis players over the course of a season or looked at estimating the regression coefficients of variables related to injury.
The results of this study demonstrate that differences in training load are evident during a training season. Training over the course of a year is designed to elicit improvements in strength, power, endurance, skill, technical and tactical readiness of players to maximize performance (
11,
37). It has previously been found that an increase in training load generally shows a higher likelihood of injury (
18,
22,
23) and illness (
23,
24) in adult athletes. Data in young athletes in other sports have suggested that training volume was positively correlated to time to first injury report (
38). However, Brooks et al. (
11) found that optimizing the recovery process after training and playing helps arbitrate the negative impact of higher training loads resulting in the low injury incidence in athletes. Furthermore, our data are in line with previous work in table tennis presenting relatively low occurrences of injury incidence in adult athletes (
8,
10). It is interesting to notice that most of the injuries in this cohort occurred during the 1st quarter of the year (65%), when training loads were significantly higher. Through Poisson regression analysis, we further established that the relative training load per minute partly explained injury occurrence but not overall training loads, the amount of training hours, or the total amount of games played. Prior to competition, the coaching staff places a large focus on table tennis specific agility and specifically on improving or maintaining endurance capacity, which results in increased relative training loads and acute injuries during this time-period. The progressive increase in training load from September to January reflects the typical progression from pre-season to competitions also observed in other sports and the consequent increase in acute injuries has been also observed in young tennis players (
17) with a potential link to training load (
39). Therefore, individually monitoring relative training load per session and fatigue in players can help with applying more individualized training sessions and reducing injury.
In this preliminary study, the rate of injury with TL was 53% with an injury incidence rate of 8.3 per 1000 hours of table tennis exposure. Data on incidence of injury in middle school sports collected over a 20-year period reported similar rates of TL injuries of 45.1% but exhibited a lower injury incidence rate of 2.7 per 1000 hours of athletic exposure (
40). Other investigations found the prevalence of injuries with TL to be higher in elite youth soccer players ranging from 63.4% - 66.5% (
41,
42). The discrepancies between studies in the literature may be explained by inconsistencies with respect to possibility of reporting bias (
9). In the study conducted by Beachy and Rauh (
39) some athletes may have had injuries that were not reported to athletic training staff. Therefore, approximation of the number of injuries could have led to an underestimation of injury incidence rates. Further, the variations in methods utilized to investigate and collect data on injury incidence explains the lack of well-controlled studies conducted, which are available in the literature. The large differences between data collection methods make comparisons difficult. Furthermore, previous studies did not examine the injury characteristics in youth table tennis athletes; therefore, making it difficult to compare our findings with similar cohorts.
Injury incidence in table tennis shows injuries in table tennis to be insignificant when compared to other sport disciplines in youth and senior athletes (
8,
9,
13-
17). It has been previously established that TL injuries in youth table tennis accounted for 89.1% with an injury incidence rate of 4.3 per 1000 hours of table tennis exposure (
9). However, our results found injury incidence rates to be much higher at 8.3 per 1000 hours of table tennis exposure in our cohort. In this study, all training and competition data was recorded using heart rate software records and a registration record, respectively. Only in 3.6% of training sessions did players not wear a HR unit, or was the data deemed unreliable because of Bluetooth connectivity issues data which meant it had to be predicted, according to the type of session performed (technical, tactical, match play, physical conditioning) and previously collected data averages for the type of session. The analysis of training load indicated that overall, the intensity of the training sessions was moderate to low (report time spent in various zones and Edwards TRIMP). This is expected, as previous work reported the cardiovascular demands of youth table tennis competitions to be relatively low (
27). Therefore, if technical and match play represents the main bulk of training activities, it is unlikely that table tennis training alone can represent a training stimulus capable of inducing improvements in aerobic capacity.
The prevalence of overuse injuries acquisition in the present study was 56%, and higher than other studies in youth athletes, where estimates of the proportion of injuries because of overuse range from 13.4% to 54% (
13-
17,
43) and like youth athletes in table tennis (62.2%) in similar cohorts (
9). The prevalence of overuse injury rates in table tennis is attributed to the characteristics of the sport, as the frequency and type of overuse injuries in elite youth athletes are related to type of training and conditioning (
44). The peculiarity of table tennis as a sport of many ball repetition bouts is an underpinning cause of the higher rate of overuse injuries when compared to other sports (
9). Overuse injuries in table tennis are because of the cumulative, repetitive sub maximal micro trauma nature of the sport, where inadequate time for recovery between stress episodes is provided to players (
8,
45). Understanding the significance of excessive loads on the human body and how they are distributed, the sports-injury mechanisms and the biochemical responses of the body tissues impacted will help further knowledge surrounding overuse injuries in table tennis (
8). While our observations only include cardiovascular demands of each training sessions, they are limited by the absence of more information about workload with reference to changes of directions and accelerations/decelerations which may be the main cause of injury in the lower limbs. For this reason, implementation of wearable technology for training monitoring (
46) might allow better quantification of table tennis demands and help explain the occurrence of acute and chronic injuries in this cohort.
The results of our study observing this small cohort of table tennis players indicated a prevalence of growth-related conditions of 24%, consistent with results found in similar study looking at youth table tennis athletes in a similar cohort (
9). Although our results highly differ from findings in other studies where incidence of growth-related conditions ranged from 0% to 16.8% (
42,
47), it is difficult to discuss the discrepancies between studies, however large differences exist in data collection procedures, maturation status and training environments. As this work was part of day to day support to the table tennis youth team, it is possible that the daily collection of data of this work is more accurate than retrospective cohort studies. Growth and maturation injuries do occur more commonly during sudden periods of growth and constitute additional risk factors for injury occurrence in youth athletes (
48). These cause additional concerns that require prevention strategies such as growth monitoring for long-term consequences to help decrease the long-term injury risk. Therefore, it is important to take a closer look at injury inciting factors and prevention plans for youth athletes for injury prevention/decrease (
9,
14).
It was established that there were no differences in the amount of injuries in the lower extremities (35%) when compared to the higher extremities (35%), and spinal injuries consisted of the rest (30%). Research which has previously looked at injuries in table tennis found that the highest number of injuries affect the shoulder girdle (
8,
10). We also found that shoulder joint injuries were a common injury especially in our junior athletes (15 - 17 years). It is believed that due to the increase in specific table tennis skill demands in training required at this age, the shoulder joints are negatively affected as a result. The short, abrupt and rapid movements required during strokes result in repetitive sub-maximal trauma of the shoulder joint due to lack of recovery and continuous training/competition schedules. Further, the processes of growth and maturation, and the physical and physiological differences between children and adults in table tennis further explains differences found in injury rates, injury severity and affected areas of injury.
Fortunately, in our cohort, 88% of injuries were minor in nature and required less than a week to return to sports activity. Table tennis is an ideal sport for adolescents because of its extremely low injury risk and severity (
8) and our data support this view. The severity of injuries in table tennis are considerably lower than other sports (
9) and further justify the use of table tennis as a sport for rehabilitation (
8). Furthermore, the relatively low cardiovascular demands might suggest its implementation in increasing activity patterns in inactive children. However, from a performance standpoint, it is fundamental to consider additional conditioning activities to improve work capacity and the ability to sustain more intense training and competition situations.
5.1. Conclusions
In conclusion, the results of this preliminary study showed that training loads increase during a season until competitions in a young cohort of table tennis players; with relative training loads being linked to the likelihood of injuries. The content and characteristics of training activities indicate a low to moderate cardiovascular demand, which reflects competitive demands in this age group. Further, the rate of overuse injuries and injuries as a result of growth-related conditions in our adolescent table tennis athletes was higher than previously reported in adolescents in other sports. Considering the peculiarity of youth adolescent athletes, it is important to improve the planning of training activities improving the understanding of the link between training load and injury occurrence. We hope that the results of this preliminary observation can be used as a reference for comparative studies in other and larger cohorts and as an initial input to conduct further studies in this popular sport.