1. Background
COVID-19 (first appeared in China in December 2019) spread worldwide in a very short time and was declared a global pandemic by the World Health Organization (WHO) in March 2020 (1). Pandemics occur due to epidemics. A pandemic is defined as “an epidemic that occurs worldwide or in a very wide area, transcends international borders, and generally affects a large number of people” (2). The pandemic adversely affects the holistic health, well-being, and psychosocial health of each individual in the community (3, 4).
The COVID-19 pandemic affected higher education across the world. Universities have started to alter their face-to-face courses with distance learning. In this regard, the most important problems faced by students are access to distance education materials (internet, computer, tablet, smartphone, etc.) and problems related to their use (5, 6).
In addition, students started to experience stress, fear, and anxiety due to the measures taken against the epidemic, changes in habits, and social isolation (5). The difficulties faced by students due to the COVID-19 pandemic are the difficulties experienced in web-based online classes from the classrooms where they are trained face-to-face, uncertainties about how to measure and evaluate the success of each course (exams), learning problems due to stress for both themselves and their families, mental health deterioration due to negative effects on psychological health, etc. (7). Especially in this process, the departments that provide practical training have experienced important problems regarding how to implement different professional practices.
One of the departments that carry out applied education in universities, especially in health institutions, is the midwifery department. With the pandemic, education in midwifery departments in faculties or colleges started to be carried out by distance education. In addition to the difficulties experienced by midwifery students regarding their participation in theoretical courses, conducting professional-practice courses (which they can experiment with and apply in health institutions, such as the hospital environment) with distance education administration may increase their anxiety, uncertainty, and their perception of hopelessness about the future.
Hope is a future-focused type of thinking. According to Snyder (8), hope is a 2-factor process of thinking as determining the goal and planning the ways to reach the goal. Emotions reflect the perceived level of hope; therefore, people with high levels of hope are more positive, happier, more optimistic, and better able to cope with their problems when they achieve their goals. During the pandemic, hope affects subjective happiness both directly and indirectly in dealing with the fear of COVID-19 (9). Solution-focused thinking (SFT) skill is a predictive factor in looking to the future with hope.
The SFT approach focuses on revealing the self-resources of individuals who aim for the future when there is no problem and that individuals do not realize to achieve this goal. Solution-focused thinking, instead of thinking about the facts that occurred in the past and caused the problem, ensures that the solution will be reached now and in the future (10). According to this approach, there is no cause-and-effect relationship between the problem and the solution. Knowing the causes of the problems does not help to construct solutions (11). Therefore, SFT offers individuals the opportunity to think about solutions instead of problems (12). It is important to use a solution-focused consultancy approach in providing students with SFT skills. It has been found that solution-focused group counseling applied to midwifery students is effective in improving the mental health of students (13).
Few studies have been found to determine the SFT disposition and/or hope levels of students in our country. According to a study conducted with students from the faculty of education, the SFT skills of female students were at a higher level (14). Bilgiç et al. (15) found that nursing students and Duman et al. (16) found that university students have high levels of hope.
Solution-focused thinking during the pandemic period can enable students to produce solutions by focusing on the future instead of thinking about their current problems (17), and this can positively affect the hope levels of students (18). In the COVID-19 pandemic, hope is an important emotion that also affects psychological well-being (19).
2. Objectives
In a comprehensive literature review, no study was found to determine the SFT and hope levels of midwifery students neither before the pandemic nor during the pandemic period. Determining the SFT and hope levels of students during the pandemic period and their relationship with each other can significantly contribute to the midwifery undergraduate education carried out with distance education.
3. Methods
3.1. Study Design and Participants
This descriptive cross-sectional research was conducted in the Midwifery Department of the Health Sciences Faculty of Ondokuz Mayıs University, Turkey. The study population consisted of 288 students (first, second, third, and fourth grade) studying in the midwifery department. No sample selection was made, and all of the midwifery department students were aimed to be reached. The study sample included 238 (82.6% of the population) midwifery department students who volunteered to participate in the study.
3.2. Instruments
3.2.1. Student Identification Form
The student identification form (SIF) consists of 9 questions to determine some demographic characteristics such as sex, age, educational information, etc.
3.2.2. Solution-focused Inventory
Solution-focused Inventory (SFI) was developed by Grant et al. to measure whether the individual shows a tendency toward SFT (12); in Turkey, its validity and reliability were confirmed by Şanal Karahan and Hamarta in 2015 (10). The scale consists of 12 items and 3 subdimensions in total. The total score that can be obtained from the scale varies between 6 and 72, and the score that can be obtained from the subdimensions varies between 4 and 24. High scores indicate high SFT. The Cronbach α internal consistency reliability of the scale was 0.77 for the separation from the problem subdimension, 0.84 for the goal orientation subdimension, and 0.70 for the resource mobilization subdimension (10). In this study, Cronbach α internal consistency reliability was 0.59 for separating from the problem subdimension, 0.80 for the goal orientation subdimension, and 0.73 for the activating resources subdimension.
3.2.3. Dispositional Hope Scale
The Dispositional Hope Scale (DHS) was developed by Snyder et al. to determine the sustained hope levels of individuals over the age of 15 (20). In Turkey, its validity and reliability were confirmed by Tarhan and Bacanlı (21). It consists of 12 items and 2 subdimensions. The total scores that can be obtained from the scale range from 8 to 64, and the score that can be obtained from the subdimensions varies between 4 and 32. As the scores obtained from this scale increase, the dispositional hope levels of individuals increase. The Cronbach α internal consistency reliability of the scale was 0.81 for the alternative paths thought subdimension, 0.78 for the agent thought subdimension, and 0.86 for the whole DHS (21). In this study, the Cronbach α internal consistency reliability of the scale was 0.80 for the alternative paths thought subdimension, 0.80 for the agent thinking subdimension, and 0.87 for the whole DHS.
3.3. Procedure
Due to the pandemic, the data collection tools were used online using Google Forms. The data were collected between 15.06.2020 and 30.06.2020. Before starting the research, written permission was obtained from the Social and Humanities Ethics Committee (decision No: 2020/312). The students who volunteered to participate in the study were informed about the purpose and content of the research, that any information obtained would remain confidential, that the data would be used within the scope of scientific research, and that their consent was obtained with an online consent form.
3.4. Data Analysis
The compliance of the variables to normal distribution was evaluated using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. Mean, SD, number and percentage values, t-test, analysis of variance (ANOVA), and Pearson correlation were used in the analysis of the data. P values less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant.
4. Results
Only female students were included in this study. The average age of the students was 20.78 ± 1.97 years (minimum, 18; maximum, 34). As shown in Table 1, 71% of midwifery students live in nuclear families, and 64.7% stated that the income of the family is equal to the expenses. The total score average of the students in SFI was 49.63 ± 5.72, and the mean scores of the subdimensions of problem disengagement, goal orientation, and resource activation were 12.97 ± 3.55, 17.68 ± 3.17, and 18.97 ± 3.25, respectively. The total score average of the students in DHS was 48.53 ± 7.18, and the mean scores of the alternative ways thought and acting thinking subdimensions were 24.75 ± 3.86 and 23.78 ± 3.99, respectively (Table 2). There was no statistically significant difference between the demographic characteristics of the students and their mean scores for SFI and DHS (P > 0.05; Table 3). There was a strong and positive correlation between the SFI total score average and DHS total score average (P < 0.001). At the same time, there was a strong and positive correlation between the mean score of all subdimensions of SFI and the mean score of all subdimensions of DHS (P < 0.001; Table 4).
| Attributes | No. (%) |
|---|---|
| Term | |
| First-grade | 68 (28.6) |
| Second-grade | 61 (25.6) |
| Third-grade | 52 (21.8) |
| Fourth-grade | 57 (23.9) |
| Family structure | |
| Nuclear family | 169 (71.0) |
| Extended family | 54 (22.7) |
| Broken family | 15 (6.3) |
| Family income status | |
| Income less than expenses | 68 (28.6) |
| Income equal to expenses | 154 (64.7) |
| Income more than expenses | 16 (6.7) |
| Midwifery department preference status | |
| Willingly | 169 (71.0) |
| Unwillingly | 69 (29.0) |
| Place to stay before the pandemic | |
| With the family | 105 (44.1) |
| With her housemate | 12 (5.0) |
| In dormitories | 121 (50.8) |
| Where she lives during the pandemic | |
| Province | 108 (45.4) |
| District | 86 (36.1) |
| Village | 44 (18.5) |
Distribution of Some Demographic Characteristics of Midwifery Students a
| Scales and Subdimensions | |
|---|---|
| SFI | |
| Problem disengagement | 12.97 ± 3.55 |
| Goal orientation | 17.68 ± 3.17 |
| Resource activation | 18.97 ± 3.25 |
| Total SFI | 49.63 ± 5.72 |
| DHS | |
| Alternative ways | 24.75 ± 3.86 |
| Acting thinking | 23.78 ± 3.99 |
| Total DHS | 48.53 ± 7.18 |
Midwifery Students’ Solution-focused Inventory and Dispositional Hope Scale Score Averages
| Variable | SFI | DHS |
|---|---|---|
| Term | F = 5.937; P = 0.115 | F = 5.369; P = 0.147 |
| First-grade | 51.08 ± 4.94 | 49.80 ± 6.32 |
| Second-grade | 48.95 ± 5.94 | 48.01 ± 6.74 |
| Third-grade | 49.28 ± 4.24 | 46.96 ± 8.29 |
| Fourth-grade | 48.94 ± 7.34 | 49.01 ± 7.39 |
| Family structure | F = 4.001; P = 0.135 | F = 1.216; P = 0.544 |
| Nuclear family | 49.87 ± 5.80 | 48.86 ± 7.41 |
| Extended family | 48.48 ± 5.86 | 48.03 ± 6.11 |
| Broken family | 51.06 ± 4.68 | 46.60 ± 8.18 |
| Family income status | F = 0.081; P = 0.960 | F = 0.562; P = 0.755 |
| Income less than expenses | 49.05 ± 7.63 | 48.26 ± 7.91 |
| Income equal to expenses | 49.82 ± 4.97 | 48.55 ± 6.50 |
| Income more than expenses | 50.25 ± 3.49 | 49.50 ± 10.17 |
| Midwifery department preference status | t = 5.029; P = 0.096 | t = 5.161; P = 0.165 |
| Willingly | 49.98 ± 5.71 | 48.86 ± 6.94 |
| Unwillingly | 48.75 ± 5.87 | 47.73 ± 7.74 |
| Place to stay before the pandemic | F = 1.386; P = 0.500 | F = 2.735; P = 0.255 |
| With the family | 50.22 ± 5.36 | 49.22 ± 6.38 |
| With her housemate | 46.41 ± 11.74 | 49.50 ± 8.06 |
| In dormitories | 49.43 ± 5.19 | 47.84 ± 5.77 |
| Where she lives during the pandemic | F = 0.504; P = 0.777 | F = 6.899; P = 0.032 |
| Province | 49.75 ± 5.97 | 49.16 ± 7.61 |
| District | 49.36 ± 5.82 | 47.01 ± 6.84 |
| Village | 49.86 ± 5.27 | 49.97 ± 6.34 |
Distribution of Solution-focused Inventory and Dispositional Hope Scale Score Averages According to Some Demographic Characteristics of Midwifery Students a
| SFI and Subdimensions | DHS and Subdimensions | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Alternative Ways | Acting Thinking | DHS Total | |
| Goal orientation | |||
| r | 0.568 | 0.564 | 0.613 |
| P | 0.001 | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| Resource activation | |||
| r | 0.632 | 0.402 | 0.552 |
| P | 0.001 | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| Problem disengagement | |||
| r | 0.340 | 0.280 | 0.336 |
| P | 0.001 | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| SFI Total | |||
| r | 0.451 | 0.355 | 0.432 |
| P | 0.001 | 0.001 | 0.001 |
The Relationship Between the Total Score Averages of Students on the Solution-focused Inventory, Dispositional Hope Scale, and Subdimension Score Averages
5. Discussion
This study aimed to evaluate the SFT skills and hope levels of midwifery students during the pandemic. According to our findings, the SFT skills of midwifery students were medium (49.63 ± 5.72), and their hope levels were high (48.53 ± 7.18).
In a study conducted with pre-pandemic education faculty students in Turkey, the SFT skills of students were at a medium level (SHI, 50.3 ± 7.71) (14), which is similar to the result of this study (49.63 ± 5.72). Unlike other university students, midwifery students receive practical training, including clinical practice (based on skills) and theoretical training (22, 23). During the pandemic, health institutions in some parts of the world did not admit students to clinics due to the increasing number of patients and the lack of personal protective equipment (24, 25).
As in other countries, hospitals in Turkey did not admit students to clinical education. To be graduates of midwifery students in Turkey was expected to complete some competencies covering pregnancy, childbirth, and the postpartum period. These competencies included 100 pre-natal examinations, attending at least 40 deliveries, caring for 40 women at risk in pregnancy, labor, or post-natal period, and caring for at least 100 postnatal women and healthy newborns (26). In addition, during the pandemic, both theoretical and applied courses were conducted only through distance education, and uncertainties regarding graduation were experienced. According to Kürtüncü and Kurt (27), the “problems in the distance education infrastructure of the university” experienced by nursing students in distance education are as follows: “Not facing education,” “limitation of possibilities,” “mood caused by the pandemic,” and “test anxiety.” In the study conducted by Rajab et al. (28) to determine the distress experienced by medical students during the pandemic, it was determined that anxiety related to the epidemic, lack of motivation, stress, and time management were among the difficulties experienced by students in distance education. It was thought that all these possible problems and situations might negatively affect the SFT skills of the midwifery department students, but the results showed that the SFT skills of the students were not significantly affected by these possible problems (P > 0.05). According to this result, it can be said that the midwifery department students’ SFT skills are above the middle level, and they think solution-focused in extraordinary situations.
Similar to the result of this study, it was found that in Turkey, nursing students in the study by Bilgiç et al. (15) before the pandemic and university students in the study by Duman et al. (16) had high levels of hope. In addition, the hope levels of sports science students before the pandemic were found to be moderate (29). In Turkey, there is a summer internship in the curriculum of midwifery departments. Midwifery students complete graduation requirements (100 prenatal examinations, attending at least 40 deliveries, 100 postnatal examinations etc.) during the summer internship. Due to the pandemic, students could not do their summer internships in Turkey and, in the world, could not be accepted to health institutions. Despite the uncertainties regarding these situations and the thought that the necessary competencies could not be completed, it was a very striking result that the students’ level of hope was high. It can be thought that students of the midwifery department maintain their hopes even in troubled times.
According to the findings, students’, grade degree, family type, family income, the status of choosing the midwifery department, the place where students stay before the pandemic, and the place they lived during the pandemic do not statistically significantly affect their SFT skills and hope levels found (P > 0.05). It was found that students with problem-solving skills in Iran experience less stress (30). In another study, a strong negative relationship was found between the hope level and perceived stress, and it was determined that individuals with high hope levels perceive their stress levels as lower (31).
In the present study, there is no significant difference between students’ grade degrees and SFT skills and hope levels (P > 0.05). But it was observed that both SFT skills and hope levels of the first-grade students were higher than those in other classes. First-grade students were with their families again before adapting to university life, living alone, and without encountering stressors such as economic responsibility for a long time. The fact that these students only experienced formal education in the first grade and were with their families for distance education at the beginning of the other period due to the pandemic may have affected this result. The fact that those who stay with their families in the pre-pandemic period have higher SFT skills compared to those who stay with their roommates or in dormitories also supports this idea.
The place where midwifery students lived during the pandemic did not affect their SFT skills and hope levels (P > 0.05). However, when the findings were examined, it was found that both the SFI and the DHS scores of the students living in the village were higher than the students living in the provinces and districts. Since the beginning of the pandemic in Turkey, the number of cases first started to increase rapidly in metropolitan cities. Later, on April 10, 2020, the curfew restrictions covering the weekends were started by the Ministry of Interior, and then travel restrictions were imposed on metropolitan cities. The low number of cases in villages and the absence of restrictions may have positively affected the SFT skills and hope levels of the students living there.
It was determined that the income level of their families did not affect the SFT skills and hope levels of the students (P > 0.05), but the students who stated that their family income was higher than the expenses were found to have higher SFT skills and hope levels compared to the other groups. Similar to this study, Ozmen et al. (32) showed that hope increases as the economic situation increases. However, the low number of students who stated that their family income was higher than their expenses might affect this result.
A strong and positive correlation was found between the mean score of the total and subdimensions of SFI of all the students participating in the study, as well as the mean scores of the total and subdimensions of DHS (P < 0.001). As the SFT skills of the students studying in the midwifery department increased, their hope levels also increased. No study investigating the relationship between SFT and hope could be found in the literature. However, there are studies investigating the predictors of SFT and hope levels. In a study conducted with adolescents, a significant negative relationship was found between SFT and hopelessness, and it was found that as adolescents’ tendency to think solution-focused increased, their feelings of hopelessness decreased (33). Hope is a future-focused type of thinking (8).
Solution-focused thinking skill is a thinking process that enables the determination of future goals, mobilization of the strengths and resources of the individual who will work in reaching the goal, and the individual frees him/her from the problem externally and directs him to his goals (12). This process explains the relationship between SFT skill and hope. Also, in other studies, a significant relationship was detected between hope and problem-solving skills (34) and psychological resilience (29), as well as between SFT and empathy (14) and happiness (33).
5.1. Conclusions
During distance education, the SFT skills of the students were above the medium level, and their hope level was high. In this period, there was a strong relationship between the SFT skills of the students and hope levels. Students with high SFT skills also had a higher sense of hope for the future. Midwives had great responsibilities in protecting, strengthening, and improving public health both in pandemic periods and in out-of-pandemic situations. For this reason, raising the SFT and hope levels of students who are future midwives is of great importance for pandemic and/or non-pandemic conditions. As future health professionals, an SFT approach that allows midwifery students to cope with mental disorders to serve in extraordinary situations should be added to educational curricula (such as solution-focused midwifery courses).
5.2. Limitations
This study was limited to the relevant sample due to geographical and social differences and cannot be generalized to other groups.
