1. Context
2. Objectives
3. Evidence Acquisition
3.1. Data Sources
3.2. Search Strategy
3.3. Eligibility Criteria
3.4. Data Extraction
3.5. Quality Assessment
| Authors | References No. | Were Patients’ Demographic Characteristics Clearly Described? | Was the Patient’s History Clearly Described and Presented as a Timeline? | Was the Current Clinical Condition of the Patient on Presentation Clearly Described? | Were Diagnostic Tests or Assessment Methods and the Results Clearly Described? | Was the Intervention(s) or Treatment Procedure(s) Clearly Described? | Was the Post-intervention Clinical Condition Clearly Described? | Were Adverse Events (Harms) or Unanticipated Events Identified and Described? | Does the Case Report Provide Takeaway Lessons? | Overall Appraisal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Molazadeh et al., 2021 | (16) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Include |
| Tzanetakos et al., 2022 | (17) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Include |
| Jakob Brecl et al., 2022 | (18) | Y | Y | Y | Y | N | Y | Y | Y | Include |
| Dikeoulia et al., 2021 | (19) | Y | Y | Y | Y | UC | N | Y | Y | Include |
| Darwin et al., 2018 | (20) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | N | Include |
| Zimmermann et al., 2017 | (21) | Y | Y | Y | Y | UC | Y | Y | Y | Include |
| Borriello et al., 2021 | (22) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Include |
| Alcala et al., 2019 | (23) | Y | Y | Y | Y | N | UC | Y | Y | Include |
| Naranjo Guerrero et al., 2023 | (24) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Include |
| Chan et al., 2019 | (25) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Include |
| Ruck et al., 2018 | (26) | Y | Y | Y | Y | N | N | Y | UC | Include |
| Bolton et al., 2020 | (27) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | UC | Y | Y | Include |
| Millan-Pascual et al., 2012 | (28) | Y | Y | UC | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Include |
| Vacchiano et al., 2018 | (29) | Y | Y | Y | UC | N | Y | Y | Y | Include |
| Lappi et al., 2022 | (30) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | UC | Y | Y | Include |
| Tsourdi et al., 2015 | (31) | Y | Y | Y | N | Y | Y | UC | Y | Include |
| Leussink et al., 2018 | (32) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | UC | Y | Y | Include |
| Durcan et al., 2019 | (33) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Include |
| Bohm et al., 2021 | (34) | Y | Y | Y | Y | UC | N | Y | Y | Include |
4. Results
| Drugs and Study | Type of Autoimmunity | Medical History | Timeline of Occurrence | Treatment | Outcome/MS Treatment | Demographic Characteristics | Year of Occurrence/Country | Target |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alemtuzumab | ||||||||
| Ruck et al., 2018 (26) | Vitiligo | MS since 2004 | 52 months after initiation, 10 months after 2nd infusion | NM | NM | A 31 year-old woman | 2016/Germany | RRMS |
| Ruck et al., 2018 (26) | Vitiligo | MS Since 2001, fingolimod | 18 months after initiation (6 month after the 2nd dose) | NM | NM | A 34 year-old A man | 2017/Germany | MS |
| Ruck et al., 2018 (26) | Vitiligo | MS since 2015, fingolimod | 14 months after initiation (2 month after the 2nd dose) | NM | NM | A 42 year-old woman | 2018/Germany | MS |
| Bohm et al., 2021 (34) | Halo naevus-like hypopigmentation | MS since 2016 | 11 months after 2nd infusion | NM | NM | A 33 year-old male | 2018/Germany | Highly reactive RRMS |
| Alcala et al., 2019 (23) | Alopecia areata | MS since 4 years ago /fingolimod | 9 months after the 2nd cycle | Interlesional steroids | Improved but new plaques occured again/NM | A 28 year-old woman | 2017/Spain | Aggressive RRMS |
| Dikeoulia et al., 2021 (19) | Alopecia areata | MS since 2006 | 18 months after 2nd infusion | Topical clobetasole then topical immunotherapy | NM | A 31 year-old woman | 2019/ Germany | RRMS |
| Tsourdi et al., 2015 (31) | Alopecia areata with hyperthyroidism | MS since 2004, smoker | 34 months after infusion | Topical mometasone but not effective | Thyroidectomy/NM | A 34 year old women | 2012/Germany | MS |
| Chan et al., 2019 (25) | Alopecia areata | MS since 2015 | 2 months after 2nd course | Interlesional triamcinolone then IV methylprednisolone | Improved and regrowth/NM | A 31 year-old woman | 2017/Canada | RRMS |
| Alcala et al., 2019 (23) | Alopecia universalis | MS since 2005; With history of vitiligo | 5 months after 2nd cycle | Not stated | His vitiligo too was worsened/NM | A 27 year-old man | 2017/Spain | Aggressive RRMS |
| Borriello et al., 2021 (22) | Alopecia universalis with Hashimoto’s thyroiditis | NM | 12 months after 2nd dose | Topical minoxidil and retinoic acid/low vid levels | No improvement/NM | A 32 year-old woman | 2019/Italy | MS |
| Borriello et al., 2021 (22) | Alopecia universalis with swelling in her hand | MS since 2015 | 12 months after 2nd dose | IV steroids+pimecrolimus+betamethasone | No hair growth/NM | A 36 year-old woman | 2018/Italy | MS |
| Leussink et al., 2018 (32) | Alopecia universalis | MS since 2014 | 6 months after the last infusion | No intervention | Regrowth after 9 months/NM | A 29 year-old woman | 2015/Germany | Highly active RRMS |
| Tzanetakos et al., 2022 (17) | Alopecia universalis with transient accommodation spasm | MS since 2005 | Fingolimod/8 months after initiation | IV and oral steroid | Roughly one year after Partial hair regrowth/continued | A 24 year-old man | 2018/Greece | MS |
| Zimmermann et al., 2017 (21) | Alopecia universalis | NM; Had received mitoxantrone before | 6 months after 2nd cycles | WHO-UMC probable/likely/not consented to any therapy | No improvement /NM | A 49 year-old man | NM/Germany | RRMS |
| Natalizumab | ||||||||
| Durcan et al., 2019 (33) | Cutaneous sarcoidosis-like reaction | MS since 2017 | Following 4th dose | Topical steroids | Poorly responsive/after 8 weeks subsided/discontinued | A 41 year-old woman | 2019/Ireland | MS |
| Bolton et al., 2020 (27) | Cutaneous lupus erythematosus with positive anti rho ab | NM | Following 2nd infusion | Oral and topical steroid then to MMF | Rash improved/NM | A 51 year-old man | NM/UK | MS |
| Millan-Pascual et al., 2012 (28) | Psoriasis (reactivation) | NM; Topical agents + MTX | After 6th infusion | UVB + topical | Slight resolution/continued | A 31 year-old woman | NM/Spain | RRMS |
| Vacchiano et al., 2018 (29) | Arthritic psoriasis | 20 years history of MS; Positive family history for psoriasis | Skin lesions, after 19th infusion and a month later, arthritis | Steroid | Partially effective/changed to DMF | A 56 year-old woman | NM/Italy | RRMS |
| Ocrelizumab | ||||||||
| Lappi et al., 2022 (30) | Palmoplantar pustular psoriasis | NM | 3 months after the last dose | Treatment with UVB and calcipotriol/betamethasone | Complete resolution/NM | A 38 year-old woman | NM/Italy | Highly active MS |
| Darwin et al., 2018 (20) | Psioriasiform dermatatis | MS diagnosed at 45/trigeminal neurolgia | 3.5 months after 2st infusion (end of induction) | 5 on Naranjo Scale/terbinafine then clobetazole | Improvement /continued | A 68 year-old woman | 2018/USA | MS |
| Naranjo Guerrero et al., 2023 (24) | Psioriasiform dermatatis/ fingernails was involved | NM | 11 months after 2nd dose | Clobetazole/partially responsive | NM/not discontinued | A 33 year-old man | NM/Spain | RRMS |
| Naranjo Guerrero et al., 2023 (24) | Psioriasiform dermatatis | NM | 4 months after 1st dose | Clobetazole topical/complete response | NM/not discontinued | A 36 year-old woman | NM/Spain | RRMS |
| Naranjo Guerrero et al., 2023 (24) | Psioriasiform dermatatis | NM | 5 months after 1st dose | Calcipo/betamethasone | NM/not discontinued | A 45 year-old woman | NM/Spain | RRMS |
| Jakob Brecl et al., 2022 (18) | Psoriasis | MS since 2020 | 6 months after 1st cycle | NA oral and topical | Moderate improvement/discontinued | A 40 year-old woman | 2021/Croatia | PPMS |
| Jakob Brecl et al., 2022 (18) | Psoriasis | MS since 2019; HTN and asthma | 1 month after 2nd cycle | NA topical | Partially regressed/discontinued | A 66 year-old woman | 2020/Croatia | PPMS |
| Rituximab | ||||||||
| Molazadeh et al., 2021 (16) | Psoriasis | MS since 2005 with migraine, bipolar disorder, seizure | 2 months after 4th cycle | Topical steroids | Improved/continued | A 39 year- woman | 2020/Iran | MS |
Abbreviations: MS, multiple sclerosis; RRMS, relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis; PPMS, primary progressive multiple sclerosis.
4.1. Alemtuzumab
4.1.1. Autoimmune Complications
4.2. Natalizumab
4.2.1. Autoimmune Complications
4.3. Ocrelizumab
4.3.1. Autoimmune Complications
4.4. Rituximab
4.4.1. Autoimmune Complications
5. Discussion
| Agents and Disorders | Findings and Proposed Pathogenesis |
|---|---|
| Alemtuzumab | |
| Vitiligo and halo naevus-like hypopigmentation | Melanocytes destruction of not-depleted melanocyte-specific CD8+ T-cells (34); Rise in interleukin-21 which drives proliferation of chronically activated, oligoclonal, effector memory T-cells (26); Increment in anti-tyrosinase antibodies and sharp rise in antibodies against tyrosinase -related protein 1 (34) |
| Alopecia areata and Alopecia universalis | Profound immunosuppression followed by immune cell reconstitution leads to an increased number of T and B lymphocytes and anti-inflammatory cytokines leading to auto reactivity and reduced self-tolerance (23); The unregulated expansion of the B-cell pool, and increase levels of B-cell activating factor leading to uncontrolled autoantibody production (22); Escaped peripheral T-cells proliferate to restore the T repertoire plus over-expression of cytokines, reduced thymic output, and the Treg/non-Treg ratio skewing (22); Immune reconstitution after immunosuppression of alemtuzumab, during which B-cells recover more rapidly than T-cells, resulting in insufficient T-cell regulation, leading to uncontrolled B-cell autoreactivity (19); Lower vitamin D levels leading to rise in interleukin-21 and -17 inducing Th17 and inhibit re-differentiation of regulatory T-cell (22) |
| Natalizumab | |
| Cutaneous sarcoidosis-like reaction | Altering expression of the α4β1− integrin, surrounding lymphocytes and macrophages of sarcoid granulomas which changes the structural extracellular matrix, inducing an inflammatory cascade and subsequent formation of granulomata (33) |
| Cutaneous lupus erythematosus | Apoptosis elevated rates are with α4β1-integrin interactions’ interference, leading to presentation of autoantigens and formation of autoantibodies (27); Disrupted signaling of α4β1-integrin important to T-cell progenitors’ thymic selection (27); Suppressed α4β1-integrin activation related to decrease in the differentiation and suppressive function of peripheral T regulatory cells (27) |
| Psoriasis | In chronic inflammation, proinflammatory cytokines’ dysregulated production leads to adhesion molecules expression rise, blockade of one of these molecules can be compensated for by other pathways (28) |
| Arthritic psoriasis | Altering laminin function (29) |
| Ocrelizumab | |
| Psioriasiform dermatatis | Depletion of regulatory B‐lymphocytes with immunomodulatory function through interleukin‐10 and proinflammatory cytokines release such as tumor necrosis factor‐α, interleukin-6 and -8 (24) |
| Psoriasis | B-cell depletion stops the B-cells regulatory effect on T-cells population (30); Preceding the release of TNF-alpha, IL-6 and IL-8, promoting angiogenesis, generating a pro-inflammatory environment, inducing keratinocyte proliferation, and attracting neutrophils (30); Increment the susceptibility to bacterial infection and modification of the microbiome (30) |
| Rituximab | |
| Psoriasis | Removal of B-cell regulatory function by controlling excessive T-cell activity (16); Induce complement activation (16) |
